Logo OpenStreetMap OpenStreetMap

Crowdsourcing oops

Postiwyd gan scruss ar 17 Hydref 2016 yn English Diweddarwyd ddiwethaf ar 18 Hydref 2016.

Statistics Canada launched their Crowdsourcing pilot today — based on imports that don’t have community approval. The editor page doesn’t even work on my browser, so I can report no further. Not a great way to start.

(Update: included link to talk-ca discussion and action)

Eicon e-bost Eicon Bluesky Eicon Facebook Eicon LinkedIn Eicon Mastodon Eicon Telegram Eicon X

Trafodaeth

Sylwadau gan Omnific ar 18 Hydref 2016 am 00:17

How is this based on imports? It looks like it’s essentially a front-end for iD, and they seem to ask people to draw buildings and add places manually. I don’t see an issue, there are already multiple tool like that (Stava Slide, etc). I say good for them for trying. The more editors the better, OSM will die if it’s a walled garden.

Sylwadau gan scruss ar 18 Hydref 2016 am 18:45

I’d refer you to this discussion: [Talk-ca] City of Ottawa imported buildings & addresses

Mewngofnodi i adael sylw