Lògo d'OpenStreetMap OpenStreetMap

Hey,
People have probably found this before, but I discovered a way to locate possible footpaths in urban areas online using Google Maps. When you go to an urban area in Google Maps in "map" mode (not satellite mode), and zoom in, it shows you the boundaries of each property. And if you look in a hilly area (e.g. Berkeley hills), every once in a while you will see an interesting "gap" (set of very closely spaced parallel lines) that streches from one street to another. This means that it is a thin strip of public land. This is a good indication of a pedestrian path. Sometimes it is not; it could be just trees or something; but more often than not it will be either a paved path, or at least a grassy passable area. Of course, you should double-check with satellite mode, Google street view, or by visiting in person. I've added several of these footpaths onto OpenStreetMap (some I'm sure are real based on street view; some very unsure). I figure, if I'm wrong, what's the worst that'll happen? (Someone will go there, find it wrong, and then delete it.) But for the ones that are right, I think it is very valuable information for the public.

Email icon Bluesky Icon Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Mastodon Icon Telegram Icon X Icon

Discussion

Comentari de davespod lo 22 de novembre 2009 a 13:22

If you are adding footpaths just based on looking on Google Maps and verifying via Google satellite view, and Google street view, you are (probably) breaching copyright.

Comentari de lyx lo 22 de novembre 2009 a 13:23

Please keep in mind that Google Maps, Satellite photos and StreetView are copyrighted material, so it is not ok to add ways based on that information only. Please visit in person or use a source that allows tracing for OSM like Yahoo aerial imagery

Comentari de Baloo Uriza lo 22 de novembre 2009 a 21:12

Did you ask Google if you could make a derivative work of their map data? If not, please stop pirating Google's map; you're probably doing more harm than good.

Comentari de davespod lo 22 de novembre 2009 a 22:11

Sorry, should have provided links to a bit more info. Definitely worth reading the following before you consider using any secondary source:

osm.wiki/Copyright

osm.wiki/Legal_FAQ#Can_I_trace_data_from_Google_Maps.2FVirtual_Earth.2FOrdnance_Survey.2F....3F

Comentari de Xoff lo 23 de novembre 2009 a 11:48

Apart from the copyright issues it is not much help IMHO to have footpaths on the map which might not be on the ground. Here in Birmingham Google added a lot of alleyways to their map but it seems to have been done from satellite imagery without checks on the ground. So, it happens quite often that these alleyways are either gated or completely overgrown and unpassable. This makes the map quite useless for planning routes on foot because you never know if the path on the map actually exists on the ground.

Connectatz-vos per ajustar un comentari