OpenStreetMap 로고 OpenStreetMap

Data Misalignment issues in Taiwan

srividya_c님이 English로 2016년 9월 13일에 게시함.

Over the past few weeks, Mapbox Data Team has been reviewing the OpenStreetMap Data quality in Taiwan with respect to Satellite imagery. By running a comparison against Bing Imagery and available GPS traces like Strava Heat Map we were seeing a notable data offset of 15-20 meters with respect to GPS Traces.

Data offset

Some observations

  • City centers have varying offset which is not aligning to GPS Traces.

  • Some major highways running between cities are having huge offset.

  • Roads in mountain areas are not matching to Strava traces

  • Some motorway junctions don’t match with the GPS Traces

tw6

Community Involvement

  • With respect to the offset and data realignment, there have been a few discussions from our side in Taiwan mailing list and Taiwan OSM group in Facebook and members of Taiwan community have expressed their support in fixing these alignment problems.

New Mapbox Satellite for Taiwan

Seeing these imagery offset issues, Mapbox Satellite is now rendered with fresh imagery for major cities in Taiwan.

image

  • New Mapbox Satellite imagery samples

tw7-mbx

Mapbox and Strava aligning compared to Bing Imagery

  • Mapbox Satellite aligning with Strava in misaligned motorway junction

tw7-mbx2

These are the cities where new Mapbox Satellite imagery is rendered. With respect to data misalignment and improvement, we hope Mapbox Satellite imagery will now enhance mapping in Taiwan!

이메일 아이콘 Bluesky 아이콘 Facebook 아이콘 LinkedIn 아이콘 마스토돈 아이콘 텔레그램 아이콘 X 아이콘

토론

2016년 9월 13일 16:22BushmanK님의 의견

It doesn’t seem like correct practice to use junctions as a reference because ramps located above the ground are usually shifted on satellite imagery due to parallax, caused by off-nadir view angle. Aligning images of ramps to tracks makes only those ramps positioned correctly - everything on the ground level gets proportionally shifted. Only ground-level features should be used for imagery alignment in case of off-nadir view angle.

I had an idea that Mapbox employees are a bit more professional in the aspects of imagery handling and basics of photogrammetry (actually, this is “Trigonometry 101” problem).

2016년 9월 14일 06:56PlaneMad님의 의견

Good catch BushmanK.

2016년 9월 17일 17:14BushmanK님의 의견

Using my “follow the error” principle of OSM Wiki improvement, I’ve added several notes to Using Imagery article.

댓글을 남기려면 로그인하세요