OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
154306677 11 months ago

Hi Rhydian
There are a few issues with this changeset.
1. You have created a duplicate amenity=fuel, this was already mapped. Please ensure you check existing features before adding duplicates.

2. It is very unlikely that the Rugby Club is pub. These are usually private for members only. It would have been correctly mapped before.

Cheers Phil

156056156 11 months ago

Unclassified in the middle of nowhere?
No gps or Strava traces
No connection to existing traces
Not added buildings
Cryptic unreadable hashtags

156056156 11 months ago

Really?

156057148 11 months ago

Hi
Please be careful not to duplicate existing objects, take a few seconds to look at the map and check if the object already exists.

Cheers Phil

155683283 11 months ago

@kitsee Your statement about a lot of OSM being imported is only partially true. Internationally a lot was imported, but in the UK we have always been very adverse to imports so here very little was imported.

Cheers Phil

155751660 11 months ago

What techniques do you believe are outdated and what are you trying to achieve?
Cheers Phil

155751660 11 months ago

Please can you post the overpass query you are using?

Cheers Phil

155741480 11 months ago

This feels very unlikely, can't imagine the neighbours being happy.

At least you have deleted it.

Cheers Phil

155751208 11 months ago

Hi Luna
Please don't delete objects and redraw them. This loses history from the database and is disrespectful to other mappers.

Cheers Phil

155605527 11 months ago

Duplicate removed as per comment left on osm.org/changeset/155605669

Cheers Phil

155605276 11 months ago

Hi
Looks like someone saw sense and restored the Bowling Green to its proper name. This is therefore a duplication so I am removing it and correcting the existing object.

Cheers Phil

155605669 11 months ago

Hi Luna
Please do not add duplicate objects to Openstreetmap. Soar Point is correctly mapped as an area and is visible on every renderer I am aware of.

What do you mean by 'seen by api'. What API as openstreetmap does not have one.

Cheers Phil

155389013 11 months ago

Bore da
This edit is incorrect, highway=pedestrian is for pedestrianised streets in town centres. This was correctly mapped as a track.

Maybe with a survey tracktype could be added but I am reverting this.

Diolch Phil

155685130 11 months ago

Bore da
Again you have made existing mapping worse, in merging osm.org/way/1188489769 into a single building you have lost that they are separate semi detached houses. This can be checked using the OSMUK Cadastral Parcels layer in iD. They also have separate UPRN (Unique Propery Reference Numbers).

Diolch Phil

155651440 11 months ago

Hi
There is already a caravan park here, mapped as an area, however you have created a duplicate node.
Please update the existing object rather than creating duplcates.

I have merged these.

Cheers Phil

155645152 11 months ago

Hi, not sure what you trying to achieve, but the pub is already mapped. Ok its a Hotel and Restaurant but thats a common issue.
However in this and your other changesets you are using some very strange tags. A pub should be mapped as amenity=pub, and optician as shop=optician. Business is not a primary tag.

Cheers Phil

155646846 11 months ago

Hi, this edit has removed existing data so has made OSM worse.

You have deleted semis mapped as building=house, where individual units are shown and replaced them with building=yes.

Remember you are working in an area with an active community and many things are already mapped. Please do not destroy the work of local mappers.

Cheers Phil

155637533 11 months ago

Bore da
Just adding buildings is pointless, its not as though in Cymru the emergency services do not have access to OS mapping, they are very unlikely to use OSM.
If you genuinely want to help OSM, although this area has active mappers, please add other useful information which is available from OS Opendata Streetview (layer in iD) such as farm names.
Diolch Phil

155606716 11 months ago

Bore da
This edit has missed important visual clues. Buildings osm.org/way/1309836157 and osm.org/way/1309836158 are not detached and osm.org/way/1309836156 is clearly a conservatory so is never going to be stand alone.

Cheers Phil

155512078 11 months ago

Hi Will
The Red Lion was already mapped and you have created a duplication. The pub is clearly visible on the map at osm.org. In the editor it shows as a building area with a black beer glass. You can see the tags if you select the building.

Also the campsite looks a bit odd, in a residential driveway? I am guessing it should be the grass area nearby.

It is very unusual to map large objects, such as campsites, or pubs, as nodes. We tend to map these as areas to show the actual extent.

The garage only needs to be mapped on the building, there is no need for a node duplicating the information.

Cheers Phil