OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
67568109 over 6 years ago

Hi, this edit has gone very wrong. You have created a route though what is clearly a private area and would have some quite serious health and safety issues.
osm.org/directions?engine=fossgis_osrm_foot&route=52.96414%2C-2.66155%3B52.96457%2C-2.67005 is clearly very wrong.
Please slow down, mapping is not a race,and consider the obvious access problems you are creating when linking public highways via what are obviously private industrial sites. Access tags are vital in this case if we are not to try routing map users through private areas thus damaging the quality and reputation of OSM.
Cheers Phil

67567911 over 6 years ago

Hi, this edit has created a series of overlapping ways. Please take care to ensure that this does not happen.

Also please consider the obvious access problems you are creating when linking public highways via what are obviously private industrial sites. Access tags are vital in this case if we are not to try routing map users through private areas thus damaging the quality and reputation of OSM.

Cheers Phil

67538089 over 6 years ago

I have already commented on a similar changeset by one of your colleages and have yet to recieve a sensible response.
Parking aisles should be mapped within a car park. There is little point in mapping them alone, Please also map the car parks at the same time as this is the object type which map users actually need.
Cheers Phil

67351640 over 6 years ago

I would also suspect that motor_vehicle=no is unlikely. It is more common that deliveries are allowed to shops during certain hours. While I know you did not add this, maybe you could check the signs. If you need tagging help just ask.
Cheers Phil

67324017 over 6 years ago

Hi, this edit is incorrect. There is no prohibition of HGVs on Flaxfield.
From looking at Streetside imagery there is a sign saying 'Unsuitable for HGVs' but that is just advice, it has no legal meaning. If you want to you could add a note saying that the sign exists but please remove this and any other restrictions that have been based on this incorrect assumption.
Cheers Phil

67355307 over 6 years ago

Hi, just wondering why you deleted the school building from Holy Trinity Acadamy?
Cheers Phil

67363098 over 6 years ago

Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for you edit but it has gone a little wrong.
Mapping unrelated objects in unrelated area of the world should be avoided as it make peer review much harder. Please remember that OSM is a collaborative database.
A golfcourse should be mapped as leisure=golf_course, it is not a park.
I am not sure what the object you have added in the US is, but it appears random and incorrectly tagged and duplicates an existing object.
I am going to revert this change, please start by adding objects in your local area.
Cheers Phil

67124517 over 6 years ago

Sorry should have added the wiki page says that they should be added within amenity=parking.
osm.wiki/Tag:service=parking%20aisle?uselang=en
Cheers Phil

67124517 over 6 years ago

Hi Yaswap
See osm.wiki/Parking

Map users will search for car parks, parking aisles alone do not add much to the map. Without the surrounding car park they are no purpose.

Cheers Phil

67145347 over 6 years ago

Hi, thank you for your edit however when adding give ways to the map please also include the direction.
Cheers Phil

67292944 over 6 years ago

Thank you

67124517 over 6 years ago

Hi, parking aisles alone do not make a lot of sense. Please take a little more time and care and add the car parks as well.
Cheers Phil

67229172 over 6 years ago

Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your edit, however adding default tags to objects is pointless and can make it harder for other mappers to spot other tags. Residential roads are by default twoway so this tag is redundant.
The time this tag is useful is when there is an odd two way road in an area where most are oneway.
Hope this gives you some guidance when making future edits.
Cheers Phil

67292944 over 6 years ago

Hi, tools such as maproulette only suggest things that may need attention. Its suggestions should not be taken literally and local knowledge should be applied.
In this case non-geographic numbers are not available from outside the UK so it makes little sense to display them in international format.
Cheers Phil

67065526 over 6 years ago

What is the source of this edit? Mapillary imagery is showing green signs here suggesting that this is not a motorway.

I, and others, have tried to contact you previously but you are continuing to ignore these. OSM is a collaborative project that relies on communication between mappers.

Cheers Phil

66791403 over 6 years ago

Hi Toby
Thank you, you cannot alter the changeset in this case, but if you can keep them to one related area in future that would be great.
Cheers Phil

66791403 over 6 years ago

Hi, welcome to OSM. Please could you keep your changes to sensible areas. Large areas such as this make it difficult for other mappers to visualise your changes.
Also what is the source of these edits, have you been to Llansantffraid?
Cheers Phil

66784201 over 6 years ago

Hi again, please could you explain the source of these edits? It is concerning when a new mapper only changes other mappers work over a wide area that they are unlikely to have visited.
Before you continue editing please answer this and other comments that have been made on your edits.
Cheers Phil

66686892 over 6 years ago

Hi, Fosse Meadows was correctly mapped as a nature reserve. It is not a park.
Also names given to housing developments are just for marketing, they do not remain after the sales people have left.

66686208 over 6 years ago

Hi, what sources are you using for this changeset?
In particular osm.org/way/23234442, OS Opendata and the names of previous mappers suggest that this was correctly mapped as tertiary.
Also, I appreciate you are new, but please could you keep your changes to sensible areas. The majority of this change is in Essex but there is this part in North Wales which makes it very difficult for mappers to visualise you changes.
Cheers Phil