Suaicheantas OpenStreetMap OpenStreetMap

Changeset Àm Beachd
152418303 o chionn 4 mìosan

If you changed "Doctor Avul Pakir ..." name, then you should also correct nearby addresses with addr:street tags and also fix nearby sreets.

But I suppose that OSM is used to tag full street names instead of "A.P.J"

157996806 o chionn 10 mìosan

Coastlines are broken.
way 1324630684 is not connected.

157845170 o chionn 10 mìosan

Ok, will fix it. I was testing a new editor in OM.

154806976 o chionn 12 mhìos

Coastlines are broken after this change. Please, check way 25865383

154813795 o chionn 12 mhìos

Coastlines are broken after this change. Please, use JOSM and validator when editing coastlines.

151058823 o chionn timcheall air bliadhna

Why coastline?

151069078 o chionn timcheall air bliadhna

Why "beach" here?

150605537 o chionn còrr is bliadhna

Coastlines were not connected and way's orientation was bad. See my fix osm.org/changeset/150642090

150605537 o chionn còrr is bliadhna

Please, use JSOM and its Validator when editing coastlines. Also, please, read OSM wiki about natural=coastline.

150470782 o chionn còrr is bliadhna

This is *not* a coastline. Please, read OSM wiki about natural=coastline tag.

147106612 o chionn còrr is bliadhna

What are the next steps here?
And here? osm.org/changeset/147054398

147388848 o chionn còrr is bliadhna

Please, read OSM wiki about coastlines before editing them. You broke the connectivity.

147054398 o chionn còrr is bliadhna

To clarify, they are connected, but not only these mentioned ways. If we are going to follow the logic with permissive and access, we need to review and retag all the nearby ways. Otherwise, routing will work not as expected, finding strange detours. It is also discussed here osm.org/changeset/147106612

147054398 o chionn còrr is bliadhna

It should be reverted from my perspective.

Broken not only shuttle access roads, but not connected with the shuttle highways:

osm.org/way/27495887
osm.org/way/27850252

147198870 o chionn còrr is bliadhna

Reverts breaking routing changes.
See the discussion in osm.org/changeset/133837637 for more details.

133837637 o chionn còrr is bliadhna

Well, I took the liberty of reverting it: osm.org/changeset/147198870

Wait until routing engines will update their data.

133837637 o chionn còrr is bliadhna

OSRM, Graphhopper and Valhalla are not working here for almost a year since this particular changeset where we are writing comments :)

147106612 o chionn còrr is bliadhna

All the Eurotunnel service roads are already mapped as foot=no, bicycle=no, horse=no, etc. access=no is strange.

What value do your changes give?

I ask on osm-gb community, they are also agree that =permissive is odd here.

147106612 o chionn còrr is bliadhna

1. access=no may technically be used to include eg foot=no , but semantically it's not nice for showing something that doesn't apply as a whole to the general public. If needed, using foot= or motor_vehicle= alone is better.
2. motor_vehcle=permissive is a very common possible mistake . It doesn't mean by "permission" , "permit" , or whatever else. It has a very specific meaning. If everyone can pay to get in, it is considered =yes .

147106612 o chionn còrr is bliadhna

I already wrote you in other comments. Your changes are controversial. Especially access=no. Please, talk to the local UK community first.