Dear user Taksine,

thank you for your numerous contriubtions to OpenStreetMap!

In your user profile you write

致力于将英语名称滚出中国和官方语言不是英语的国家。

which sounds like your plan was to delete name:en/int_name tags from places where English is not the official language. Can you please clarify that in your profile, and either explain that you will not be deleting name:en/int_name tags, or remove that sentence entirely.

In one recent changeset you commented “Clean up these nodes that have been repeatedly added, have completely incorrect tags, and seriously violate local language rules.” and deleted a couple of all-caps place markers in the UAE. It is acceptable to delete things that are duplicates or otherwise useless, but “violating local language rules” (in this case, using English rather than Arabic) is not a sufficient reason to delete anything,

Six days ago in osm.org/changeset/163195334 you deleted a number of roughly-drawn residential areas and announced that you would re-draw them, but you have not done so yet. It is always preferable to improve the accuracy of something that exists, rather than deleting it altogether; if you do delete something and replace it, please replace it in the same editing session and not weeks or months later.

You also write

本人坚决维护国家安全，所绘画的区域来源一律为公开资料，涉及危害国家安全问题的一律不会画，有时会删除掉。

which sounds like you plan to delete valid data on the grounds of national security. While I understand that it might be necessary for you to write that in order to be able to map in China in the first place, please understand that removing valid data from OSM is considered vandalism and is not allowed, even in cases where data present in OSM can be perceived as being against the law in China.

Finally, could you please avoid empty changeset comments (osm.org/changeset/163426847), or meaningless comments like “d” (osm.org/changeset/163350994), “C” (osm.org/changeset/163278691), “1” (osm.org/changeset/163185622), or “啊” (osm.org/changeset/163109975)?

Thank you
Frederik Ramm
OSMF Data Working Group