OpenStreetMap 로고 OpenStreetMap

Think bout boundary of INDIA

AJAY_VSV님이 Telugu (తెలుగు)로 2013년 6월 6일에 게시함.

ఓపెన్ స్ట్రీట్ మ్యాప్ వారికీ ధన్యవాదములు Greetings to all,

భారతదేశపు సరిహద్దు, మరీ ముఖ్యముగా పాకిస్తాన్ - భారత సరిహద్దు, జమ్మూ వద్ద సరియైనది కాదు. (Boundary of India, mainly at Jammu i.e. Pakistan-India boundary is not so exact to belief.)

దీనిని సరియగు సరిహద్దుగా మాపింగ్ చేయమనవి…(Please map the correct boundary for the both nations)

అజయ్ కుమార్ ములకల AJAY KUMAR MULAKALA రాజమహేంద్రి. Rajahmundry

위치: استور تحصیل, ضلع استور, دیامر استور ڈویژن, گلگت بلتستان, పాకిస్తాన్
이메일 아이콘 Bluesky 아이콘 Facebook 아이콘 LinkedIn 아이콘 마스토돈 아이콘 텔레그램 아이콘 X 아이콘

토론

2013년 6월 6일 09:29SK53님의 의견

I suspect that you think that the boundary of India should include all of the pre-partition States of Jammu and Kashmir. However it is policy for OpenStreetMap to map what is on the ground. This effectively means that we try and map the Line of Control accurately, rather than areas claimed, but not controlled by India or Pakistan (and indeed China).

The reasons for this are straightforward, OSM is used in countries on both sides of border disputes and therefore it is impossible to adhere to both views of where notional borders might be. Furthermore OSM, unlike, say the maps of the Survey of India, does not serve political purposes. OSM is not a platform for fantasy maps, whether those created by individuals or mandated by legislation by governments.

I realise this may create problems for people in India where it may be an offence to represent the boundaries of India other than according to the states wishes, rather than any accordance with reality. For that purpose I would suggest using an external source for the boundary of India: moving the boundary away from the LoC will be treated as vandalism.

If on the other hand the boundary needs minor tweaks (which I’m sure it does) and you can map them based on personal observation or sources which are open, usable in OSM, and readily available for others to check that such mapping is accurate then do go ahead.

I have also answered this on [OSM Help](https://help.openstreetmap.org/questions/23042/how-could-we-edit-the-boundary-of-india-and-pakistan_.

댓글을 남기려면 로그인하세요