OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
85463803 over 5 years ago

Hello Sophia,
Let me explain the system again
(I've send you a message through Slack as well.
Due to the nature of this country the project team made specific guidelines how and what to map.
These are collected and available in the documents pinned to the Slack Channel.
This is one of the most important docs
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SxLkCU3IRecsFV2kYx61VImJLLtQiKw3/view
The aim is to made a digital/paper maps network of roads /paths connecting hamlets, villages, towns to be able to get (nav systems) access even to the very remote groups of people.
We are not interested in tracks leading to farm fields ,woods or rivers. Just roads connecting the community. Very basic.
About your answer.
Stop after 4. changeset number and forget the OSMCha website. This is mend to be used by OSM (semi ) professionals to get grip on vandalism and mappers who consequent made bad mappings.
Let me know if you have further questions.
Best regards and keep mapping

85428559 over 5 years ago

Your mappings are somewhat weird. See my comment to you on Slack
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/85428559

85445160 over 5 years ago

Hello Michael
May I remind you on the guidlines how to map in these regio?
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SxLkCU3IRecsFV2kYx61VImJLLtQiKw3/view
Please map accordingly,
When buildings are in the proximity of highways there is no need to map the acces ways to them
Best regards

85446207 over 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping here.
I've got an idea that you missed the introduction on Slack and the guidelines how to map on this project. I might be wrong. If you did. forget then this message.

Please introduce yourself on this channel and let your mappings review by experienced validators. They guide you to the correct way how to map here.

https://join.slack.com/t/crowd2map/shared_invite/zt-dhhcwlkg-ROTlhoST1Rsz9Edhm67hsw
You made the typical errors new mappers often made. No problem and this is not criticizing you, but see this as a guidance to map in accordance to the requirements.

Please pay also attention on the issues which did show up when you wanted to upload your mappings. See the issue triangle in the right hand menu of the editor
They should be solved before uploading.
Please read these documents as well and map accordingly ( they are part of the introduction process.

https://crowd2map.slack.com/files/U4HH3QGJZ/F013B50QQMT/_crowd2map_get_started_rev_5b.pdf
*

https://crowd2map.slack.com/files/U4HH3QGJZ/F013PEPF48G/image.png

*

https://crowd2map.slack.com/files/U4HH3QGJZ/F0111KAF0SK/guidance_for_road_tags_in_rural_tanzania_rev_4.pdf

This course covers the way how to map in Ideditor.

https://learnosm.org/en/beginner/ .

At least test your knowledge with this Quizz.

https://crowd2map.slack.com/files/U4PQD1WFK/F012XU6CYC8/quiz_building_mapping_skills.pdf

Best regards and keep mapping

85462177 over 5 years ago

Hi. See my remarks on another changeset of yesterday
Best regards
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/85462177

85463243 over 5 years ago

Hi. See my remarks on changeset 85463803
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/85463243

85463803 over 5 years ago

Hello Sophia. Thanks for mapping here
Did you not join the Slack channels to introduce yourself and get your first attempts reviewed?
Please Do and read the pinned documents on the hotmappings channel
Read this to get a good understanding what and how to map in these projects
About your mappings,
After reading the guidelines you will see what went wrong with your mappings.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/85463803

85407515 over 5 years ago

Hi again
Please pay also attention on the Issue triangle on the right side of the menu
It shows errors which have to be solved before you upload them
Best regards

85407515 over 5 years ago

Hello . Thanks for mapping here.
Haven't you read the guidelines how to and what to map on this project?
You mapped way to much "living streets"and unclassified highways without checking if the trace on the ground is wide enough to call it a highway unclassified.
Most of the buildings are in the proximity of the through going road and the access road/paths to them are not needed to be mapped. ( read the guidelines pinned to the Channel in SLACK
The tag linving street is mend to be used in dense urban areas. not here on the countryside. The most used highway tags here are unclassified , path and track, when they lead to
farmland. wood or river/lakes
Best regards

84154195 over 5 years ago

Hello Deanna, Thanks for mapping here
A small issue. When you map buildings, never connect nodes to another features like paths or highways, Please check the guideline what to map, you map paths which are not necessary.
Please square your mapped buildings with the Q key in the editor. You missed some.

Best regards and keep mapping

83309104 over 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping here.
Please follow the guidelines on this project. ( Pinned to the newmapperfeedback channel on slack.)
Try to be more precise in mapping buildings. Don't include the shadow in your mapping. And always square the rectangular bulidings with the Q key in the editor.
Best regards and keep mapping

85432040 over 5 years ago

Hello. I invalidated your work here because you did not use the most recent Imagery Maxar !! Please use Maxar at all mappings on this project
Best regards

85393774 over 5 years ago

See the PM on Slack
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/85393774

85118043 over 5 years ago

Hello Saif. Did you have a good understanding what and how to map>
You just mapped residential areas instead of all buildings. Please open this changeset again in Editor, remove the mappings of residential areas, not required, and map missed buildings.
Please let me know the changeset if you are ready with that
Best regards
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/85118043

85120571 over 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping here. I reviewed this task and noticed that you use the Bing Imagery. Please switch to Maxar since that is the most recent. Bing image is dated from 2011 - 2016. Since then much has been changed. You mapped buildings which has been disappeared
And do not forget to square the buildings you map with The Q key in the editor
Best regards
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/85120571

85166521 over 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping here.
I am reviewing your mappings and have some remarks.
The buildings are (except round huts) rather rectangular. please keep that in mind during mapping. Where a tree hide a part of the roof, extrapolate the building. Don't follow the line of the tree.
Please square each building you map with the Q key in IDeditor.
Best regards

84913849 over 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping. (see my PM)
about this task. Please do not connect nodes of buildings to other features like highways and residential areas.
Pay also attention on the warnings on the triangle on the right hand menu and solve them if possible
Best regards

85293666 over 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping
Please follow the guidelines which highways
should be mapped. You map a bit to much in detail. (See the comments from my colleague)
The paths leading to the buildings are less than 200 mtr . free view. no nee to map.
best regards

Best regardss

85268444 over 5 years ago

Hello Carmen. Thanks for mapping here.
A remark. A building shows mostly a shadow next to it. When there is no shadow (open field) It is mostly no building>
object smaller than 2 mtr are no subject for mapping.
Best regards

85266022 over 5 years ago

Hello Carmen83.
A remark. You Validated this task !
Please wait with validation till you are very experienced (+250 changesets)
Validating work will be done by experenced validators.
(update: Validating is now limited to intermediate and advanced mappers)
Best regards