OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
87259107 about 5 years ago

Hello
Thanks for mapping
A remark. Please review your knowledge how to map and tag objects. You called waterways, very meandering a track and even as a main highway ! Please take a look to these pages
osm.wiki/Highway_Tag_Africa
osm.wiki/Key:waterway
I will correct these
Best regards

84460285 about 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping
A remark. You mapped here very meandering traces as track. These traces are mostly streams or small rivers. I change them
Please keep an eye on the right hand menu of the editor and solve the issues which pops up before uploading your work
Please refresh your knowledge how to tag highways. Use track only as access to farmland, woodland etc. When it deliver access to farms, dwellings, hamlets etc use unclassified (rural areas)
See this wiki
osm.wiki/Highway_Tag_Africa
Best regards

84697875 about 5 years ago

Hi . thanks for mapping the bulk of the buildings in this task.
Unfortunately there are some issues which require additional work on this task: All (253) of the buildings are mapped having a non square shape. This is highly unlikely for a real building. We can safely assume that buildings are rectangular in this area unless we can see that this is not true.
As outlined in the instructions please do not let individual buildings share nodes - map them as separate objects. Although buildings may be connected in reality we run into a problem here. If someone wants to fix the shape of a building it automatically distorts the surrounding buildings making any cleanup a lot more difficult.

Please square all buildings (rectangular) with the Q key in the editor
Most buildings are good rectangular and the mappings should reflect that.
A hand drawn building is mostly not correct squared. Therefore use the Q key after calling it a building and the object is still selected.
Be aware that this will not work when the deviation to a square corner is to big. Then you have to adjust the building manually . After that you can square it again.

We (validators) have to spend a lot of time to deal with these issues

84661219 about 5 years ago

Hello
Thanks for mapping here
About highways
Please read the wiki how to map/tag highways
osm.wiki/Highway_Tag_Africa
You mapped unclassified highways , correct, then a track goiing of that road into the countryside where you mapped a few sideways and tagged them as unclassified. This is not logic.
A track is used for entree to farm- woodland. Unclassified as connection between hamlets etc.
Please check also the issue triangle on the right hand menu
You overlooked a few warnings
Best regards and keep mapping

84474963 about 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping here.
A remark.
Please square all buildings (rectangular) with the Q key in the editor
Most buildings are good rectangular and the mappings should reflect that.
A hand drawn building is mostly not correct squared. Therefore use the Q key after calling it a building and the object is still selected.
Be aware that this will not work when the deviation to a square corner is to big. Then you have to adjust the building manually . After that you can square it again.

Another issue is the collecting of multiple buildings and map them as 1 building. This is not the correct way to map buildings.
Please map each building individually and be aware to not include the shadow of that building in your mapping.

Never let a node of a building connect to other features, like highways, other buildings or residential areas
Let highways never cross buildings as well.
Navigation systems cannot handle these situations

Please pay also attention on the issue triangle on the right-hand menu
It alerts you on warnings and errors.
Please (try to)solve these before uploading your work.

Best regards

87218041 about 5 years ago

Hi Daniel.
Please tag highways in agriculture area not as 'residential" Just use unclassified, path or service. 'residential is to be used in urban (dense) areas
osm.wiki/Highway_Tag_Africa
Best regards

84882128 about 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping here
a few remarks,
Don't overlap buildings and map them as accurate as possible, excluding the shadow line next to the building. Always square a building with the Q key in the Editor
Best regards and keep mapping

84658715 about 5 years ago

Thank you for mapping
A remark. You should note one thing. The instructions tell us to map all buildings individually. You mapped several neighbouring buildings as a single shape. This is not helpful in disaster response and preparedness when organizations on the ground want to visit every house or do damage assessment.
Best regards and keep mapping

87143727 about 5 years ago

kan ik ook een bericht naar een ander sturen?
@franswillem

84394163 about 5 years ago

Hello
Thanks for mapping here
A remark.
Please square all buildings (rectangular) with the Q key in the editor
Most buildings are good rectangular and the mappings should reflect that.
A hand drawn building is mostly not correct squared. Therefore use the Q key after calling it a building and the objcect is still selected.
Be aware that this will not work when the deviation to a square corner is to big. Then you have to adjust the building manually . After that you can square it again.

Never let a node of a building connect to other features, like highways, other buildings or residential areas
Map each building individually. do not cluster buildings and call it 1 building

Please pay also attention on the issue triangle on the right-hand menu
It alerts you on warnings and errors.
Please (try to)solve these before uploading your work.

84846072 about 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
A remark. You map many clusters of buildings and call them 1 building.
Please map each building separately and accurate. Also square each building with the Q key
Best regards

84464893 about 5 years ago

Hola. Gracias por el mapa
Un comentario.
Por favor, cuadren todos los edificios (rectangulares) con la tecla Q en el editor
La mayoría de los edificios son buenos rectangulares y los mapas deberían reflejar eso.
Un edificio dibujado a mano no es en su mayoría correctamente cuadrado. Por lo tanto, use la tecla Q después de llamarlo edificio y el objeto sigue siendo seleccionado.
Tenga en cuenta que esto no funcionará cuando la desviación a una esquina cuadrada sea demasiado grande. Entonces tienes que ajustar el edificio manualmente. Después de eso puedes cuadrarlo de nuevo.

Nunca dejes que un nodo de un edificio se conecte con otras características, como autopistas, otros edificios o áreas residenciales
Mapea cada edificio individualmente. No agrupes los edificios y llámalo 1 edificio (lo que hacías frecuentemente).
Voy a invalidar esta tarea (28) y le pido que remapee los edificios combinados en edificios individuales.
Por favor, presten también atención al triángulo de temas en el menú de la derecha.
Te alerta sobre advertencias y errores.
Por favor, (intente) resolverlos antes de subir su trabajo.
Hello. Thanks for mapping
A remark.
Please square all buildings (rectangular) with the Q key in the editor
Most buildings are good rectangular and the mappings should reflect that.
A hand drawn building is mostly not correct squared. Therefore use the Q key after calling it a building and the objcect is still selected.
Be aware that this will not work when the deviation to a square corner is to big. Then you have to adjust the building manually . After that you can square it again.

Never let a node of a building connect to other features, like highways, other buildings or residential areas
Map each building individually. do not cluster buildings and call it 1 building( which you did frequently.)
I am goiing to invalidate this task ( 28) and ask you to remap the combined buildings to individual buildings.
Please pay also attention on the issue triangle on the right-hand menu
It alerts you on warnings and errors.
Please (try to)solve these before uploading your work.

85464365 about 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping
Please be more accurate in mapping and do not collect multiple buildings and map it as 1 building
Also square each building. Don't you use the Building tool in JOSM ?
Best regards
Hola. Gracias por el mapa
Por favor, sea más preciso en la cartografía y no recoja varios edificios y lo cartografíe como un solo edificio.
También cuadrar cada edificio. ¿No usas la herramienta de construcción en el JOSM?
Saludos cordiales.

84796077 about 5 years ago

Hello
Thanks for mapping here
A remark.
Please square all buildings (rectangular) with the Q key in the editor. None of the buildings you have mapped are fair squared.
Most buildings are good rectangular and the mappings should reflect that.
A hand drawn building is mostly not correct squared. Therefore use the Q key after calling it a building and the object is still selected.
Be aware that this will not work when the deviation to a square corner is to big. Then you have to adjust the building manually . After that you can square it again.

Never let a node of a building connect to other features, like highways, other buildings or residential areas
Map each building individually. do not cluster buildings and call it 1 building

Please pay also attention on the issue triangle on the right-hand menu
It alerts you on warnings and errors.
Please (try to)solve these before uploading your work.
Best regards and keep mapping

84845832 about 5 years ago

Hello Wei Xia Pui

Thanks for mapping here
A remark.
Please square all buildings (rectangular) with the Q key in the editor. None of the buildings you have mapped are fair squared.
Most buildings are good rectangular and the mappings should reflect that.
A hand drawn building is mostly not correct squared. Therefore use the Q key after calling it a building and the object is still selected.
Be aware that this will not work when the deviation to a square corner is to big. Then you have to adjust the building manually . After that you can square it again.

Never let a node of a building connect to other features, like highways, other buildings or residential areas
Map each building individually. do not cluster buildings and call it 1 building

Please pay also attention on the issue triangle on the right-hand menu
It alerts you on warnings and errors.
Please (try to)solve these before uploading your work.
Best regards and keep mapping

86729841 about 5 years ago

Hello
Thanks for mapping
you called this task as unavailable. Why?
All objects are very good to map.
Please just stop mapping if you are not sure everything is ok. other, more experienced mappers /validators will pick these up.
Please don't add a name tag with question. if you want to have another mapper take a look to it just add a tag 'fixme' with the description

About highways. The aim is just to map roads which matters.

Roads needs to be connected to other roads if possible.
Common used tags for highways in rural area are 'unclassified' and 'path' .The tag ' residential' is to be used in more dense urban areas
Check if they can carry 4 wheel cars. When it is just a narrow trace leading to buildings they are mostly paths.
you can measure the width of a road:
ctr +shift+M shows measurements
click on the line between the nodes and you get the width.

86343892 about 5 years ago

Hello Micheal.
I was reviewing task and noticed the taggings of highways in this changeset
Please refresch your knowledge how to tag highways. Here, local streets has been tagged as secondary highway ( regional main connections)
Should be residential.
See this wiki (suitable for tagging here as well
osm.wiki/Highway_Tag_Africa
I changes them
Best regards

85623861 about 5 years ago

Hello Beza
Thanks for mapping here. Quite buzy !
Just a few remarks
Please tag buildings just as building=yes.
See instructions
When you map bridges over rivers, always add the tag layer=1 to the bridge. This brings the bridge a level higher.
Don;t you use the Validation tool and the mappaint style inline validation?
See for more usefull tools
https://www.missingmaps.org/assets/downloads/MissingMaps_validation_josm_en.pdf
Best regards

85906982 about 5 years ago

Hello Michael
Thanks for mapping here
During review I was attended on mismapping of bridges. You tagged several times layer= -1 instead of 1 or +1
I corrected it
The bridge is a level higher than the river ,(ps Don' t you use the validating tool and the inline validating paint style? They tackle these and more issues)
Best regards

86450353 about 5 years ago

Hi John. Thanks for mapping here
A remark.
The way you place a ford is not correct
You took a piece of road and tagged it as a ford. The correct way is connect a node of a waterway and the node of the road and join them together. tag it as ford=yes
The ford symbol should show up,
Best regards