OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
73663205 almost 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping
First of all. You marked this Task as Bad imagery. Why" Bing ( which you used as well as Maxar P shows perfect image)
First check the instructions which ask for MAXAR P Imagery. This is since it became available ( begin july) it is the preferred Imagery, Bing is outdated. You can see that when you select MAXAR as imagery. Quite a number of new buildings shows up.
These has to be mapped as well.
I invalidate this task
Best regards

73644431 almost 6 years ago

Here you mapped a few spots as a building.
Always look for a shadow which means that an object is above ground level. Also if a building is round or rectangular.
No shadow means no building.

73644431 almost 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping
First of all. Please switch to the MAXAR P Imagery. ( see the mapping instructions) This is since it became available ( begin july) it is the preferred Imagery, Bing is outdated. You can see that when you select MAXAR as imagery. Quite a number of new buildings shows up.
These has to be mapped as well.
You can map them as well when the task is still in the mapping status. Let me know if it is marked as complete mapped. I can invalidate it so it will be available again for mapping

Do not forget to square all rectangular buildings.
Best regards

73683380 almost 6 years ago

Thanks for mapping
I review tasks of (new) mappers to check if they comply to the requirements, are free of errors and of a good mapping quality.
.Please square all rectangular buildings you map with the Q key in iD editor in future mappings. You can also keep the Q key pressed down and select the buildings each after each other,
Best regards and keep mapping

73160558 almost 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Please review your mapping skills. Your mappings are rather inaccurate and not squared.

73270573 almost 6 years ago

Hello Francesca . Thanks for mapping here.
A remark. Please pay more attention on accurate mapping. your mappings are somewhat inaccurate.
Don't forget to square all your buildings with the Q key in ID editor
Best regards and keep mapping

73902981 almost 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
A remark. Please use the Imagery which has been mentioned in the instructions. You used the Bing Imagery which is rather old. Maxar is more recent.
You can reopen this changeset and add missing buildings
Please do not forget to square the buildings with the Q key in ID editor
Best regards and keep mapping

73561456 almost 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Please be more accurate in mapping. You mapped L shaped buildings just as a rectangular building. Please follow the outlines as good as possible
Best regards and keep mapping

73903715 almost 6 years ago

Hello danyonramsay, Thanks for mapping
A team of validators review work of new mappers to check if they are mapped according the instructions and of a good quality.
In general your mappings are complete but not square and often a bit imprecise. Please map each building accurate and square them with the Q key in ID editor.
Best regards and keep mapping

73467508 almost 6 years ago

Hello . Thanks for mapping.
You used the Bing imagery for mapping instead of the MAXAR P imagery.
You also modified highways into one way ( Dead end roads !!) This is a building only project. No need to spend time on highways. (You ignored the warnings of these errors on ID editor. you ought to correct these ,
Best regards and keep mapping

73360248 almost 6 years ago

Hello Daryosh Arsalan.
Thank you for joining this project.
Despite the time you spend on mapping here your mappings are of a very poor quality, You used the wrong Imagery ( Please read the instructions) Maxar P is the imagery to use. Buildings are to be tagged as building=yes. Do not include several buildings as being 1 building.
I have to revert the mappings of this changeset because it cost more time to correct everything rather than starting all over again.
Please be so kind to remap these buildings Task 1312
Best regards and keep mapping

72785004 almost 6 years ago

Hello Jenny. Thanks for mapping on this project. Validators review work of new mappers to see if they are confirm the requirements and of a good mapping quality
In your case I have following remarks
Your mappings are rather inaccurate and not all buildings are squared. Use the Q key in ID editor each time you square a building.
Do not connect building nodes to another building.
Please do not collect several buildings and map it as one building
Open attached link to see your mappings
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1XcpSYQBewtAoAQFm1Jl9Ohe56PBGzk7P
I see you mapped these with the Bing Imagery, Please use for future mappings on this project the Maxar imagery, Much newer and clearer
Best regards and keep mapping

73903867 almost 6 years ago

Hello Somya Sahu
Thanks for mapping on this project.
Validators review mappings of new mappers to see if they comply with the requiments and of good quality.
in your case i am sorry to tell that you did not square any building. Use the Q key in ID editor each time you map a building.
Be also more precise in mapping.
See attached page
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1rHPGdCM12WfN_bRYOsXIaS4Zav0zuAIz
See the mappings in red (yours) and the lower picture.
Most buildings are strict rectangular or L shaped.
You also ignored a warning in ID editor for mapping buildings over each other. You ought to correct these.
Best regards and keep mapping

72119474 almost 6 years ago

Hello Sully
Thanks for mapping. Please square all your rectangular buildings with the Q key in ID editor and try to be more precise in mapping
Best regards and keep mapping

70667762 almost 6 years ago

Hello SarahO1
Thanks for your contribution. I'm marking this task invalid as the mappings on the majority of houses is not correct. You need to trace the outline of the building. Have a look at the 'Learn' pages, and this guide on mapping in iD Editor: http://learnosm.org/en/hot-tips/tracing-rectangular-buildings/
On This webpage you can see the way you mapped buildings. ( in general they are strict rectangular)
https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=70667762

Please read the instructions on the project as well. There has been asked for the MAXAR P imagery. You used the Bing imagery which is very old and outdated,
So there are many more buildings to be mapped,
Always square the buildings you map with the Q key in iDedtior.
Did you not see the warnings on the Editor when you mapped 2 buildings over each other ? You could solve that very easily.
Best regards and keep mapping

73610967 almost 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Urgent request.
Please use the MAXAR P imagery to map from. The Bing Imagery, which you are using now is very old and outdated. Maxar P is listed in the instructions as the imagery to be used. On attached webpage you cans read how you can select another imagery
https://learnosm.org/en/beginner/id-editor/#configuring-the-background-layer

Best regards

73609620 almost 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Urgent request.
Please use the MAXAR P imagery to map from. The Bing Imagery, which you are using now is very old and outdated. Maxar P is listed in the instructions as the imagery to be used. On attached webpage you cans read how you can select another imagery
https://learnosm.org/en/beginner/id-editor/#configuring-the-background-layer

Best regards

73609872 almost 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Urgent request.
Please use the MAXAR P imagery to map from. The Bing Imagery, which you are using now is very old and outdated. Maxar P is listed in the instructions as the imagery to be used. On attached webpage you cans read how you can select another imagery
https://learnosm.org/en/beginner/id-editor/#configuring-the-background-layer

Best regards

73611054 almost 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Urgent request.
Please use the MAXAR P imagery to map from. The Bing Imagery, which you are using now is very old and outdated. Maxar P is listed in the instructions as the imagery to be used. On attached webpage you cans read how you can select another imagery
https://learnosm.org/en/beginner/id-editor/#configuring-the-background-layer

Best regards

73610335 almost 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Urgent request.
Please use the MAXAR P imagery to map from. The Bing Imagery, which you are using now is very old and outdated. Maxar P is listed in the instructions as the imagery to be used. On attached webpage you cans read how you can select another imagery
https://learnosm.org/en/beginner/id-editor/#configuring-the-background-layer

Best regards