OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
34548911 almost 10 years ago

Thanks for the information. I understand now that this is a very special case.
I changed the tag to highway=bus_stop a few days ago, now I am unsure what to do.
I guess the best would be to remove the highway=bus_stop tag and only keep the node?

35109232 almost 10 years ago

sorry for the late reaction, I was offline for a while. Before I started changing the ways with the highway=residential_link I searched for any hint when it should be used and only
found a discussion in a german forum which came to the conclusion that minor roads don't have link roads. I am not sure if my translation is 100% correct, but also OSM Inspector and the renderer of osm.org don't seem to "like" this tag.
I just read the posts in the list and found no comment which says that my change is wrong, but of course I can revert it if you want me to do that.

2160985 almost 10 years ago

okay, thanks for the feedback.
I don't feel like a newly-converted, but
yes, I am eager to reduce the number of
(now) ambigious tags ;-)

20292566 almost 10 years ago

please review:
the tag
highway=residential_link should not be used,
the *_link tag is only useful for major roads.
Does this way really exist ?
osm.org/way/259136210

34905816 almost 10 years ago

@pascal_cyclist:
Just to make sure:
osm.org/way/368900734
You have deleted this way again. I am not a local, so I have no idea if that way exists and how it looks like.
I just tried to point out that the tag highway=tour should not be used
for any way.

35111900 almost 10 years ago

please review:
some ways have the invalid tag
highway=primary;residential
now.

34883087 almost 10 years ago

prima, danke für die Rückmeldung

34929193 almost 10 years ago

thanks for the quick feedback. The easiest way is to look at the history of the way:
osm.org/way/82253108/history
Use the attributes of the way before your change

34929193 almost 10 years ago

please review:
the tag highway=residential_link is not
useful, it should be just residential.
But is the road already built?
osm.org/way/82253108

17847698 almost 10 years ago

please help me to understand:
why do you map a "virtual" way?
Sample:
osm.org/way/238049099

2160985 almost 10 years ago

please review: do you still think that a waterway=weir should also be mapped
as a highway=stepping_stones ?
I know the tag ford=stepping_stones,
but this doesn't seem to fit either.

32396622 almost 10 years ago

Noch keine Idee?

35068972 almost 10 years ago

please review:
osm.org/changeset/35104083
What does side=down mean ?
osm.org/node/3123708783
Is also used here:
osm.org/node/3592246056
See also
osm.wiki/Key:traffic_sign

35068935 almost 10 years ago

please review:
I think you accidently changed the ways to highway=give_way, see
osm.org/changeset/35103982

15188347 almost 10 years ago

Do you think that this might also match here?
osm.org/changeset/15340040

30389103 almost 10 years ago

bitte prüfen: Ich vermute, da ist was schiefgegangen. Ein highway=moving_walkway wäre ein Laufband.
Meine Änderung:
osm.org/changeset/35102833

28385996 almost 10 years ago

please review: The tag highway=towpath
is only used here, it should not be used for a normal path which is also used as a towpath.
See also
https://help.openstreetmap.org/questions/42811/should-a-towpath-be-under-highway-or-waterway
As these ways are not connected to any other highway I've changed the highway=towpath to a note for now.

34905816 almost 10 years ago

@Alex3271:
The tag highway=tour is rarely used,
if you know better what it is, please change it. The word tour doesn't mention the vehicle. I assume it is a highway=path,bicycle=yes,foot=yes ?
The same tag is used here
osm.org/way/368900734

33590174 almost 10 years ago

please review my changes:
(prosimy przejrzeć moje zmiany)
osm.org/changeset/35099061

31407844 almost 10 years ago

Bitte prüfen:
Habe das schwer zu deutende
highway=unofficial_path
in
highway=path
access=private
geändert.
osm.org/changeset/35099014