OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
97761406 over 4 years ago

Also please don't only express your opinions at changeset comments. It's not expected to be seen as a forum for discussion.

97761406 over 4 years ago

If you would calm down, you can see this connects to Expressway area. It would be prudent to tag both as `=motorway_link`. A similar issue is encouneterd on Ma On Shan Bypass, due to partial interchanges.

97528846 over 4 years ago

Please check that there's `ownership=private` for the section inside the area.

97530445 over 4 years ago

You can use `landuse=cemetery` + `informal=yes` for an area, and `cemetery=grave` for an individual grave. `amenity=grave_yard` has to be associated with a religious feature (eg ` amenity=place_of_worship`).

81538679 over 4 years ago

osm.org/way/776702788/ is not a truthful representation since there are no psychically separated slip lanes. The turning restriction is also unnecessarily set up, with legal restriction already tagged on the road.

97434245 over 4 years ago

1. 8 Waterloo Rd hasn't been properly formatted. Since the `addr:housenumber=` applies to the entire area, it shouldn't be tagged on individual buildings to avoid duplication. (for simplicity firstly)
2. `addr:city=` isn't really necessary, but a more serious issue here is Kowloon is both a `place=city` and `place=region` (`admin_level=5`)
3. There's no `addr:postcode=` in HK. Having any value is not correct.

97413475 over 4 years ago

1. `=trunk_link` is tagged because it is Exit 1 on Route 7. Ignoring this, `=*_link` still needs to be continuous.
2. There's a problem with braided roadways and lane restrictions. I assume `=trunk` is kept to reflect Exit 8, but it should possibly be moved to the diverge upstream.

97489760 over 4 years ago

Please check that there's a 4-lane parallel merge section here. It's not a direct taper merge.

97470527 over 4 years ago

Ma Yau Tong appears to be large enough to be a `=village`

97470527 over 4 years ago

`natural=saddle` and `mountain_pass=yes` are different as well.

97470527 over 4 years ago

Most importantly please don't tag this `source=`

97470527 over 4 years ago

Also "Lai Chi Kok" in this case could refer to the entire hill body, not exactly the peak.

97470527 over 4 years ago

Lai Chi Kok is specifically the cape below the hill. I found some references to a Lai Chi Kok hill, and there's staff quarters of LCK Reception Centre (not counting the hostel), so the `natural=` and `place=` (inhabited) could be separated.

97458466 over 4 years ago

It seems to be a one-storey base topped with a park.

97351376 over 4 years ago

These are `=pedestrian` as they physically allow four-wheeled, two-tracked vehicle access; used for maintenance and emergency.

97351567 over 4 years ago

Some map data add these because they are derived from paper maps, or have limited functionality.

97351567 over 4 years ago

It's counterproductive to add "ex", "proposed", "construction of" when tags already indicate its status. For good measures, this is already reflected in `description:*=`.

97295353 over 4 years ago

`=sports_centre` is debatable, but obviously not make an extra `=pitch` around the proper `=pitch` within.

97295353 over 4 years ago

You seem to have deleted more roads than you have added.

97274172 over 4 years ago

Please only add `bicycle=no` etc if there's a legal restriction (eg forbidden by sign). Use other tags for suitability, eg `smoothness=`, `mtb:scale=` and `mtb:scale:imba=`