Kovoschiz's Comments
Changeset | When | Comment |
---|---|---|
151479189 | about 1 year ago | 1. This is not `tunnel=yes` . `covered=` is already used. At most, we can debate whether it should be `=building_passage` , but there's no "building" left or right at ground level. Please don't edit for validators.
|
150794937 | about 1 year ago | Please don't delete directly, as they represent a shop space, and may contain an address. Change it to a plain "point" to eliminate it. |
151128479 | over 1 year ago | Please notice these info should be added on the site osm.org/way/124697425 , not the `building=` |
150770681 | over 1 year ago | Please don't blindly correct, or make uninformed assumptions. There is a noticeable sidewalk here. The existence of `footway=sidewalk` doesn't affect that. |
150736746 | over 1 year ago | Please don't delete shops with addresses. Change them to a plain "point". |
148542015 | over 1 year ago | Please use `branch=` and not add that to the `name=` (unless that's really part of the original naming as in hotels) |
150485040 | over 1 year ago | 6. `=site` is not neccessary in the simple 2D case of all objects inside a polygon. It's only needed for complicated 3D situations. |
150485040 | over 1 year ago | 5. Don't use uppercase |
150485040 | over 1 year ago | 4. Please stop adding "號" in `addr:housenumber=` |
150485040 | over 1 year ago | 1. Please stop adding lot info on `landuse=` directly. This is not the standard practice locally.
|
150415859 | over 1 year ago | On the contrary, there are footbridges between buildings that aren't enclosed, eg Central Elevated Walkway between Hang Seng and 100 QRC (considering Exchange Square section to be a separate section). Or they may connect between "outdoors" part at the top of the podium (Can't think of an example yet, but Yeung Uk Rd Market has an outdoor hub at NIna Square). Then these may not be `building=bridge` . |
150415859 | over 1 year ago | For clarity, what I had in mind:
Of course, many other `bridge=covered` are mistakes... If something is considered a `building=bridge`, thus `indoor=yes` , logically the `bridge=yes` might be redundant. This is especially the case in more significant `building=bridge` (depending on interpretation` ) eg IFC across Man Cheung St as actual "buildings" with shops inside. |
149895936 | over 1 year ago | For `aeroway=terminal` + `building:part=` which I can't quickly find yet, what I thought is it's common for 1 `building=` to be divided into domestic and international terminals.... |
149895936 | over 1 year ago | Ok maybe they aren't, but as I said, this definition of `=terminal` is overly dependent on `building=` vs `building:part=` Still, why should connector parts that don't check-in or access to aircraft be `=terminal` ? I don't see any reason in that. As you may have asked above, this causes questions on other connectors, people mover stations, train station, parking, etc. |
149895936 | over 1 year ago | I don't understand your take on `aeroway=terminal` + `building:part=` cases. They are proper terminals, not `=concourse` . By such definition, only `aeroway=terminal` + `building=` is valid. Are they wrong? |
150415859 | over 1 year ago | It's unclear how others deal with them, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Covered_bridge#Roofed_bridges
|
150415859 | over 1 year ago | If these are defined as `bridge=yes` + `indoor=yes` (what's the use of `covered=yes` then?) , it creates the question of why aren't fully enclosed `bridge=covered` the same? The presence of openings that aren't covered by windows? |
150415859 | over 1 year ago | Originally, it wasn't defined for timber only osm.wiki/w/index.php?oldid=1550838#Bridge_key:_ways_and_relations |
150415859 | over 1 year ago | Admittedly, `=covered` is used for "covered" wooden bridge. But that could be `covered=yes` + `bridge:material=wood` . `indoor=yes` don't fit for these, unless you consider these to be `building=bridge` , which is inapplicable.
|
150415859 | over 1 year ago | `bridge=yes` + `indoor=yes` would be a a walkway on a bridge indoors. It would further be interpreted as indoors of the landscape deck here, which doesn't have an indoors space. `covered=yes` is for the top only. They don't describe the sides. |