OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
163616572 5 months ago

2. MOS Rd has a fork with MOS Bypass. It continues, not being an entry or exit. Bypasses are usually considered forks, not using `=*_link` on the bypassed road.

163616572 5 months ago

This was already discussed. It will be changed to `=primary` to the Sai Sha devleopment when Sierra Sea has population intake. Lok Wo Sha Ln and Nin Ming Rd doesn't justify a `=primary` yet.

163544439 5 months ago

This doesn't translate the actual `name=` . It's already described in `description=` . Please don't add such descriptor labels that aren't proper names. osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only

163501577 5 months ago

Please don't make up random translations on your own. There's already the English naming around here.

163501488 5 months ago

Please don't use machine translation, especially if you can't even choose Japanese correctly. Your Mandarin didn't even translate "古".

163225639 5 months ago

Please don't make literal transliterations. This is not even what the mountain is called. `name=` is a proper name commonly used only. Machine-like translations are not needed.

163424104 5 months ago

Please don't change this `disused:railway=` to `railway=crossing` . It isn't functional. No trains travels pass it.

163236442 5 months ago

You need to be cautious with recognizing what's a "name". These are usually titles or descriptive label. When you see a webpage, item, link, or document, etc, named that, you should not immediately assume it's a `name=` , especially with these prefixes. Is it "舊羅湖鐵路橋" or "前羅湖鐵路橋"? Is it "Old" (that's the `name=` added before by others), "Former", or your "Preserved"? This can't be agreed on. Adding these prefixes also interferes with proper names with these words, eg Old Town or Old Market can be a proper name.
Names should be considered as what will be recorded on nameplates and signs, following the ground truth principle. If the bridge has a plaque, It will be "Lo Wu Bridge" only. Similar to how "Beacon HIll Tunnel" is carved on the previous KCR tunnel, not modified as "Old Beacon Hill Tunnel" etc.
Another perspective to look at this is how `man_made=` is a physical structure similar to `building=` . This bridge deck has only been moved here. It has no other changes. It's still the same "Lo Wu Bridge".

163273890 5 months ago

2. Please don't delete properly tagged objects

163273890 5 months ago

1. Please don't directly delete, as they still represent a store space, and may contain an address. This makes tracking and updating difficult.
2. Please don't delete then create the same feature again. This is meaningless, and obstructs tracking.
3. Please use descriptive upload comments, not signing your name

162912820 5 months ago

Please don't blindly follow suggestions, as they may be incorrect. "Matsukiyo" is used in HK. https://www.matsukiyo.hk/rwd1509/Store/OwnImage/logo-20220711.png https://www.matsukiyo.hk
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:HK_KTD_觀塘_Kwun_Tong_APM_mall_shop_Matsukiyo_Store_October_2022_Px3_01.jpg

163236442 5 months ago

Please don't add such descriptor labels to `name=` , which is for proper names only. `old_name=` is already added. If needed, use `description=`

163234880 5 months ago

Please don't upload test edits to a live public database. This is vandalism.

163227519 5 months ago

2. It's not necessary to draw curves following the vehicle driving track / swept path. You can think of how it works at intersections, where the round street corner radius isn't represented directly. So the lane doesn't need to be followed according to the marked line, and the inner side. Drawing straight according to the outer side is the best from experience. This is specially the case for such roundabouts that would leave extremely short segments from an entry to the next exit.

163227519 5 months ago

The slip lanes are split at exactly the tip of the hatched area to follow the physical separation rule as much as possible. The geometry is indicated by `placement=transition`

163224575 5 months ago

`=permit` is defined as a travel pass always granted, not for HK and UK "permit" signage. If only staff and players are allowed, it's should be `=private`

163115545 5 months ago

Please stop opening new accounts to dodge questions and replies. This doesn't work for public traffic. Please don't Tag For Renderer.

163094465 5 months ago

`=roundabout` must have a segment between an entry and the next exit. They can't connect directly. It will confuse applications as if vehicles doesn't pass through a `=roundabout` and can turn left directly.

162954690 5 months ago

osm.org/changeset/162248937

162954690 5 months ago

osm.org/changeset/153239869
osm.org/changeset/154786130
osm.org/changeset/157093615