OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
100088417 over 4 years ago

Please don't remove road lanes and crosswalk info.

100061360 over 4 years ago

The only exception may be Broadwood Rd -- Link Rd, but it's still dwarfed by Stubbs Rd and Tai Hang Rd, as well as Morrison Hill Rd.

100062246 over 4 years ago

5. I accept DVRC westbound west of Pedder St as being the same as eastbound when considering the entire roadway, which is mostly undivided. However QUeensway obviously has a main route into QRC.

100062246 over 4 years ago

Gloucester Rd here is obviously more important than the rest.

100062246 over 4 years ago

The northern half of Arsenal St isn't as important,

100062246 over 4 years ago

Hysan Ave -- Hoi Ping Rd for Caroline Hill Rd shouldn't be considered as the same as the latter.

100062246 over 4 years ago

Please explain why `bus=private` is wrong.

100061360 over 4 years ago

Doubt roads south of Leighton Rd are as important as Percival St, Marsh Rd -- Tin Lok Ln -- Canal Morrison Hill Rd, Canal Rd, Stubbs Rd, Tai Hang Rd. They are mainly for Happy Valley, Caroline Hill, and Leighton Hill only. Thse are still local through traffic.

100015314 over 4 years ago

The problem is the intersection opening is quite long, effectively creating an geometrically offset intersection between Tong Hang Rd and osm.org/way/886107366/ that is restricted crossing (only left turn into the latter is allowed)
However, as a rule, divided roads won't be joined up at an intersection.
Let me see what I can do.

100015314 over 4 years ago

To be more accurate, the western and eastern ends are physically divided. The central section is opened up.

100015314 over 4 years ago

This is half correct, half wrong. The western section is physically divided.

10000000 over 4 years ago

Happy ~9.5 year old birthday

100000001 over 4 years ago

You are the 1st!

100000000 over 4 years ago

Oh god this is going to be the most changeset comment ever

99999999 over 4 years ago

Thanks and congratulations on changeset #99999999

99970554 over 4 years ago

Please don't add descriptor labels to names.

99918805 over 4 years ago

Please don't upload for-fun edits. This is vandalism.

99910406 over 4 years ago

@rayleigh1 Thanks for trying to fix it, but the info needs to be retagged, rather than only removed. I have no idea if the climate is sufficient to determine, with only `=evergreen` and `=broadleaved`. Would you mind if I re-instate them as `tree=palm` (there are still ~30k archaic `type=palm` instances) and `taxon=Arecaceae` or equivalent? (also not sure if fixing certain edits constituents mechanical editing)

99911716 over 4 years ago

When it comes to "don't add individual trees like this", this may be acceptable up front if it is a plantation or tree nursery with permanent physical and marked growing spots.

99777800 over 4 years ago

`species=` is not strictly appropriate. There's a `tree=palm` for general use (previously `type=palm` had been used without regards), following `trees=` suggested in `landuse=orchard`. Technically, if `family=Arecaceae ` looks too ambiguous and weak, `taxon=Arecaceae` (and possibly `taxon:family=Arecaceae `) could be used.