OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
120484114 over 3 years ago

1. I have already told you to make comments before. Why would you accuse others of " insufficient local knowledge;"?
2. Roads are only splitted when there is physical separation.

120493435 over 3 years ago

Please don't change unopened features to opened yet. The usual practice is to do it at midnight.

120300052 over 3 years ago

Please don't upload test edits. This is vandalism.

120281348 over 3 years ago

Please flush your cache, or tell your application to update and fix. This has already changed to `old_name=`. It still exists. Correct the name only if it is wrong. Don't delete it.

120237170 over 3 years ago

Please don't use `=hamlet` if they are deserted. `place=locality` + `abandoned:place=hamlet` (may also be a `=isolated_dwelling`)

120204600 over 3 years ago

Use `alt_name=`.

120204600 over 3 years ago

`name=` is for proper name only. No brackets please. This is not a printed map that needs labels.

120189764 over 3 years ago

1. It's not "excessive" if it exists. They are simply defined as high points and low points. It's up to applications and renderers to show them with priorities.
2. Please see osm.wiki/Tag:natural=ridge#Examples eg osm.wiki/File:Druim-Eileasaig-z14-opencyclemap.png and osm.wiki/File:Walker-Ridge-z14-from-Opencyclemap.png --- They don't have to be very sharp and exposed on top, or like a `=arete`.

120175679 over 3 years ago

Please don't just delete it. This looks to be valid, if only improper representation. It's likely a `=strait` or something.

120158034 over 3 years ago

Please don't disconnect this if it still exists.

120154802 over 3 years ago

1. Please don't delete them. They still represent something in reality. They are already changed to `old_name=`. Please flush your cache, and tell your application to update or fix.
2. Descriptive changeset comments please.

120157972 over 3 years ago

Please don't mass delete.
1. They may contain address info that doesn't change. In iD, change to the plain "point" preset to keep them.
2. They still represent a shop space. Ideally use `was:shop=` or `was:amenity=`. This helps identify which shop space they are exactly, and track changes.

120031912 over 3 years ago

What's wrong with the `natural=peninsula`?

120030044 over 3 years ago

This positioning is therefore wrong in OSM. OSM is not a printed map. You put thing at where it is at exactly. Don't map for renderer.

120030044 over 3 years ago

It is partially based on paper maps. It is also a single-layer online map, not an entire map database with many renderer and applications as OSM. You should not copy from any other map directly anyway.
As I said, HP1C seems to contradict this. I haven't checked iB1000. Different maps by the same source can be different.

119355351 over 3 years ago

Can you please discuss with osm.org/user/Whcohi at osm.org/note/3146813 concerning the name?

120030044 over 3 years ago

3. Please don't copy directly from paper maps. Their label position is affected by artistic choice and printed presentation.

120030044 over 3 years ago

Putting a `saddle` hillside is also meaningless.

120030044 over 3 years ago

The `=suburb` (even if you disagree with it as a sub-district) is not the same as the demolished `=saddle`.

120028555 over 3 years ago

2. I'm not talking about any Custom Pass, whatever it is.