LivInTheLookingGlass's Comments
Changeset | Cuant | Coment |
---|---|---|
161608426 | 7 mês indaûr | Thank you. I was just moving a bit too quickly. I'll be more careful for the remainder of this set |
38800812 | cirche 7 agns indaûr | Hi! I was hoping to ask about your tagging here. I think that this is not correct. If you can explain your reasoning as to why driveways are tagged as areas (instead of driveways) and people's backyards are buildings, then I would be happy to hear it. If I don't hear back in a week or so, I will start to re-work these areas. |
58666728 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Sorry for the incorrect description there. It autofilled and I forgot to change it. |
58657197 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Thank you! |
58534086 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Nah, there's no need. This is still a valid and common way to do things. I only wanted to warn in case you end up working on something more complicated. |
58534086 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Okay, note that this is a nitpick, and I do the same thing most of the time, but it's a bad habit to have areas that share a boundary. It can pretty much always either be a relation that shares a line for the boundary, or not be connected. But that's a total nitpick, and this is definitely fine. It's only a real concern when you start getting very complicated sets of connected buildings.
|
58532886 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | This is definitely how basketball courts should be mapped.
|
58532821 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Only real complaint here is that the pool should only cover the actual pool. In addition, it doesn't have that roof mapped right next to it, though that may show up in one of your later changesets. Basketball court should cover only the court. Same with the soccer pitch. Not sure about the tennis ones, I think that's good. Also, I'm *way* jealous of the quality of imagery in your area. I would say this changeset is good on the whole.
|
58532034 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Hi! Thank you for editing in the Marquette area. I really appreciate the help. If you're looking for more to do, there's a tracker for areas in Marquette + Trowbridge that don't have building outlines here: http://tasks2.openstreetmap.us/project/98 |
57746425 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Hi! Thank you for editing in the Marquette area. I really appreciate the help. If you're looking for more to do, there's a tracker for areas in Marquette + Trowbridge that don't have building outlines here: http://tasks2.openstreetmap.us/project/98 |
57923526 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Hi! Thank you for editing in the Marquette area. I really appreciate the help. If you're looking for more to do, there's a tracker for areas in Marquette + Trowbridge that don't have building outlines here: http://tasks2.openstreetmap.us/project/98 |
58532192 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Hi! Thank you for editing in the Marquette area. I really appreciate the help. If you're looking for more to do, there's a tracker for areas in Marquette + Trowbridge that don't have building outlines here: http://tasks2.openstreetmap.us/project/98 |
57372840 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Is that how it's supposed to be tagged normally? If so, the iD defaults disagree. |
57214085 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Hi. When adding building outlines, please take care to have them match the actual building's geometry. Having looked at your recent edits, it looks like you're just putting rectangles for every house, but that is not accurate.
|
57163728 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | That said, I dont know that's the proper way to do it, just that its the common way in northern Michigan. Might be leftover from before it was standardized. |
57163728 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Most of the time I see it mapped as a building=roof with the properties of the gas station merged in, and a building with the convenience shop tags behind it. ID will do this for you if you use the BP presets, and then change the names. |
57179840 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Please do not name houses unless they explicitly have a name. For instance, the White House. Otherwise this looks good, and thank you for contributing.
|
57169774 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Please use more accurate changeset messages
|
57169733 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Hi. I went back and reverted this so that the tagging matches the other airport roads, but if you have local knowledge saying I'm wrong, please feel free to change it. I just want to have the airport be tagged consistently
|
57169730 | plui di 7 agns indaûr | Please use more accurate changeset messages
|