Hi,

please do your CS comments in Italy in Italian or English

Thank You

Hi,

There appear to be 2 forest relations top of each other, a V7 which is properly closed and a V7 which is badly broken but follows a large part of exactly the same forest as the V7. Think the V17 has to be deleted. See osm.org/relation/1583796

What you think?

ciao

Hi,

Think the contact:phone needs to be changed phone:tollfree as QA wants the E123 format on phone and contact:phone incl intl prefix. Numero verde can go to https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/phone%3Atollfree#overview

ciao

Road and railway corridors mapping continued thru large wood relation, prepping to split. Remove bridge from railway, change to tunnel for track. Many inner details added, outlines refined.

PS First section cut off of prox 85 members, mapped another 65 inner areas into osm.org/relation/17444351. Countless 'inner' still to do. Left fixme note for later mappers, half the wood is really agri land and other landcover.

So taginfo says name:uk is used for A name in Ukrainian. You defenitely got me there

https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/name%3Auk#values

And I did put both before of one in an ASCII editor and it shows no difference on my computer.

Hi,

Given the battle over Russian-Ukraine name tagging, are you sure the name:uk here is in russian too?

osm.org/node/31517557/history

I had extreme strong doubts and this was just a random test since this popped into my mapping 'territory' so I did a second random pick and that one too gets name:uk in russian.

osm.org/node/31491325

ciao

NB Think Torrente Vallone del Santo and a nameless stream East-West and West-East from the mountain comb can be used to do a further 'natural' split of the 455 member forest relation. Needs some work again.

NB: A number of forest inside areas qualified as meadow WITH buildings on them were in past not made proper inner to forest, probably for render purposes. osm.org/relation/17432250
They are clearly visible in winter imagery i.e. just the summer canopy is hiding them whole or part. Think it would be proper to assign the inner roles. Also the buildings on the meadow need to have their inner areas, residential, farmyard, what ever the ground they're on qualifies these.

PS, it's actually done, the tertiary from Brustolotti to Ronchi as separator. ALSO, changed the Parco naturale regionale della Lessinia relation from multipolygon to boundary. Have asked at JOSM GitHub to add regional_park to the admin_boundary, national park render style for better recognition in the JOSM editor.

Hi,
Finally got round to start cutting up large member count forests in your region with my 'repair' account. This one was 713 members, now 4 ways, the largest 243 where the recommended is a maximum of 300.
osm.org/relation/957743/history/202

The one that was 1683 members has already lost several sections, the original has about 1100 left but needs some more studying how to proceed further as I don't want to cross thru inner areas of e.g. bare rock and scree that still need mapping.

ciao
Rob

Hi,

Thanks for mapping in Italy. Notably you've created multiple duplicate ways in town and the large circular at the west. The latter is actually not a roundabout as there are 2 stop signs in the ring. I've corrected that one.

Kindly take care of the duplicate ways in Catanzaro. Where they are exactly you can see in this map by OSM Inspector, the dark blue lines.

https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=routing&lon=16.59526&lat=38.90223&zoom=19&baselayer=Geofabrik%20Standard&opacity=0.50&overlays=duplicated_edges%2Cislands_car%2Cunconnected_open_ends_1

Strangely there's now e.g. an alley way on top of steps by the name of
Discesa San Francesco di Paola. We can't have 2 ways on top of each other and why the alley is now on layer=1 suggests there's a bridge, but no bridge=yes tag (think ID Editor makes it too easy to just add a layer tag when 2 ways on top or ways crossing buildings)

Happy mapping & thanks
Rob

PS When mapping in Italy, please do your change set comments in Italian or English which most mappers understand, Czech we don't speak ;O)

Ciao, sì, ma hai rotto il contorno italiano allo stesso tempo evidenziando l'ispettore OSM.

https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=14.82163&lat=40.64371&zoom=15&baselayer=Geofabrik%20Standard&opacity=0.50&overlays=duplicate_node%2Csingle_node_in_way%2Cduplicate_segment%2Cway_in_multiple_rings%2Cintersection%2Cintersecting_segments%2Cring_not_closed%2Ctouching_rings%2Crole_should_be_inner%2Crole_should_be_outer%2Cinner_with_same_tags%2Cways%2Cduplicate_node%2Csingle_node_in_way%2Cduplicate_segment%2Cway_in_multiple_rings%2Cintersection%2Cintersecting_segments%2Cring_not_closed%2Ctouching_rings%2Crole_should_be_inner%2Crole_should_be_outer%2Cinner_with_same_tags%2Cways

Rob

Hi,

Vi prego controlla l'edificio che hai importato con MapWithAI e verifica nelle immagini satellitari se la sagoma corrisponde alla realtà, p.e.
osm.org/way/1265041253
Questo problema si presenta con ogni singolo edificio preso da MWA e lo stesso vale per le vie. Devi correggere ogni singolo elemento.

ciao

Escape CS: Correct comment is: landuse/cover, ways, lay refinements, destinations/directions, road details, maxspeed, smoothness, marking tags, stop spot. Cocullo train station details, platform, footway. Tunnel details, narrow, below default height.

So, after second survey not interrupted by rain, civ 2 thru 12d mapped, brand new shields, but not from yesterday, different model with street name below, the shield for 1 is gone at post office, left over the mail drop box (photo in cloud), don't ask me when that happened but suspect same time as the new 2-12d series were placed. There's 2x 10, Poste Italiane web site says theirs is 10A (10a per Istat dictate). The cemetery seen all from 1 through 18 except 2 and 15. A florist told those were just gate numbers for the visitors (presume emergency services too). The cemetery is officially at Chiarini 1 (there's a cemetery website "Find A Grave" even giving the Cemetery ID: 2737452, civ number 1 is at the main gate. Strictly speaking 16,17,18 are physically on Bruno Madonna. 3-14 east side, I'd say Chiarini as it's on a path extension from the main gate and parking with the noted bollards.

Oh, and opening hours, found 3 boards, 3 different times, the one on nr7 does not mention October. covers Apr-May, Jun-Sep, Nov-Mar. Different hours per season.

Hi Martin,

Really, so how did you get to this one, according my daily log somewhere on the 18-19th jan 2022. That was being led by example and by the nose of a 'I have been here many years' mapper who resides somewhere in the L'Aquila region. Stopped doing that roundabout 2 years ago too. He was/is Multipolygoning all and everything, building sides inclusive, maddening... When I get to these, by chance, I rip these apart, as me and ivanbranco (mostly) had and have been doing all over the area for farmland in particular.

At any rate, think it's a good idea to acquaint oneself with new works of a mapper before issuing KISS reminders ;O)

cheerio

PS The civ.nr shields say Città di Montesilvano above. Many villages in the area only print their names on civ.nr shields, never a streetname. In Villa Raspa they make sure you know you're in Spoltore :O)

1) civ 3-14 relate to the address of the cemetery, not Togliatti. Added footway from parking to nr 7. There's steep stairs there and a board with 3 seasons opening hours. Also there's bollards there to prevent cars going in to drive to nr 3-6.
2) The post office stretch is 2 to 14 with 10+10 sub on concrete pillar right front of post office + 12+12b, building further down.
3) completed a turn restr. where via was missing and smoothed some roundabout flare shapes.
4) Added roles to the Togliatti relation.
JOSM warned for a bunch more... next time.

You put it there... osm.org/node/11728064512 sans addr:street

Shop POI on first floor, no address, no addr:floor too. Where's that documented?