OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
96122989 over 4 years ago

Hello, the boundary is now broken:

osm.org/relation/6066126#map=14/10.9434/-74.8144

95883518 over 4 years ago

Thank you for this fix. I'm surprised JOSM doesn't flag that as a warning.

95710894 over 4 years ago

It has also broken the boundary of Sydney.

95710894 over 4 years ago

Hi there - looks like this change messed up the border of Brooklyn. There is a way dangling off of it.

95655098 over 4 years ago

Can you clarify where I've made an error so that I might correct it? Sometimes in the polygon cleanup I might grab a nearby street node inadvertently, and sometimes the street does separate adjacent landuses.

95259200 over 4 years ago

Looks like Duarte is also broken, see: osm.org/relation/9319973

95259200 over 4 years ago

Hi, this city boundary is quite broken - please take a look at: osm.org/relation/5547859

87369448 over 4 years ago

Tagging of state parks is definitely a challenge... see osm.wiki/Proposed_features/Park_boundary

94854817 over 4 years ago

I'm pretty sure Carto doesn't support this tag. Perhaps open a ticket? https://github.com/gravitystorm/openstreetmap-carto/issues

94288505 over 4 years ago

Hello, you deleted a piece of the boundary - please fix this!

93828947 almost 5 years ago

There was a missing piece of the boundary. The line was on the map, but it was not in the boundary relation.

93828947 almost 5 years ago

I had fixed Scharloo earlier, but I was able to see where the boundary was supposed to be in that case.

93828947 almost 5 years ago

That link is to the OpenStreetMap US server. But many people from other countries are on it as well. It is easier to communicate there than changeset comments.

All of the boundaries I am seeing are fixed now, thanks!

93827403 almost 5 years ago

I just fixed the Punda boundary also, the segment existed but it wasn't in the boundary relation.

93828947 almost 5 years ago

The eastern boundary is completely missing when you look at: osm.org/relation/7237830

I'm not sure about iD, but in JOSM they are reported as errors.

I see these errors because I operate a web site that uses boundary data. When they break, I see that they are broken.

If you are able to get on Slack chat (https://slack.openstreetmap.us/) I would be happy to help you more.

93827403 almost 5 years ago

Looks good! I added the missing "outer" boundary relation roles. The boundary for Punda (osm.org/relation/7237830) is still broken.

93828947 almost 5 years ago

This boundary also is missing a section: osm.org/relation/7237830

93827403 almost 5 years ago

I trust that you will choose the correct location of the boundary! As long as it forms a complete loop.

93827403 almost 5 years ago

Hi, if you load osm.org/relation/9507096 into a web browser, you should see that a piece of the boundary is missing.

93827403 almost 5 years ago

Hi, it looks like the boundary relation for Berg Altena (9507096) was left in a broken state?