OpenStreetMap 로고 OpenStreetMap

Who is adding administrative boundaries ?

ablansinger님이 English로 2008년 7월 19일에 게시함.

For some weeks ago I noticed that a road (way 13523361) suddenly had become an administrative boundary with germany on the left side. I also noticed that the change had been added by a user "anonymous".

Today I noticed that the entire eastcost line of denmark (eg. way 4120237), from the german/danish border and up to tha danish city Kolding, had benne tagged the same way as administrative boundary with germany on the left side. And again it was added by a user anonymous.

Can anybody explan what is happening ?

위치: Skibelund, Kolding, Kolding Municipality, 6092, Denmark
이메일 아이콘 Bluesky 아이콘 Facebook 아이콘 LinkedIn 아이콘 마스토돈 아이콘 텔레그램 아이콘 X 아이콘

토론

2008년 7월 20일 16:40chillly님의 의견

It looks like someone has created a user 'anonymous' ...

2008년 7월 20일 17:01ablansinger님의 의견

And this someone is then putting incorrect administrative boundaries on roads and costlines in the mittle of denmark ?
Well it can be true ! but couldnt it be some kind of automated import that is "out of control" ?

2008년 7월 21일 15:54smsm1님의 의견

You could try sending the user a message?

2008년 7월 21일 16:45Andy Allan님의 의견

It's not a user called "anonymous", it's an anonymous user. Remember, we have several thousand user accounts that are indistinguishable and we can't contact the users - it's only potlatch that enforces making your edits public.

2008년 7월 21일 19:22ablansinger님의 의견

Hmmm that would mean there is no way to know what was the intention with the changes, and in worst case we can be changing it back and forth until one resigns.

I am using the potlatch editor, and has only shortly looked at JOSM, but it
seems that even with JOSM a login is required to upload changes, or ?

How is it possible to upload ways without being properly registered ?

I thought that it was some kind of automated import of data from a license free
data set (could be that the was a free definition of the german borders), I have
read that this kind of import have been used in other cases. How can such imported data be recognised ?

댓글을 남기려면 로그인하세요