OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
73417791 almost 6 years ago

A zase. To by ma zaujimalo, cim ste zmerali ten travnik v kruhaci osm.org/way/295880164 , ze je podla Vas mensi ako ukazuju vsetky snimky.

Je Vam dufam jasne, ze priemerovanim GPS v zakrutach Vam prirodzene vyjde nieco uplne ine ako je poloha cesty, kedze mnohi zaznamenavaju polohu v dlhsich intervaloch a teda z tych par bodov presnu polohu cesty nedostanete. Ak ste pouzili len jedno vlastne meranie (stale neviem akym pristrojom), tak to tiez nie je smerodajne.

71026211 almost 6 years ago

Okrem toho posunutie bodu osm.org/node/5486028 hned k mostu je uplne zle, ciara cesty ktora odbocuje, ma zacinat na konci odpajacieho pruhu (teda ako bola) a nie na jeho zaciatku. osm.wiki/Lanes
Javi sa mi, ze ste to uz takto chybne urobili na viacerych miestach, tak prosim nastudujte stranku a zacnite robit spravne, aby ste nekazili uz dobre cesty. Dakujem

71026211 almost 6 years ago

Zdravim, ake prosim pouzivate gps zariadenie, ze je podla Vas presnejsie ako vsetky letecke snimky, co mame k dispozicii? Neustale pridavate stovky bodov a posuvate cesty a napriklad v tejto sade zmien pri Sladkovicove sa mi to nezda byt nijakym prinosom, skor ste dobre vyzerajuce cesty zase pokazili a nesedia na snimky. Rad by som teda dokaz, podla coho si myslite, ze Vase upravy su spravnejsie. Okrem toho neuvadzate ziadny zdroj udajov (co by ste mali), co na doveryhodnosti zasahov nijako nepridava. Dakujem

71306795 almost 6 years ago

Maybe you used entrance=yes as "entrance to an enclosed area" (per the wiki), but even then not all cases are like that. But in all cases you missed the node is also part of a barrier for which the barrier=entrance is needed to make a hole in it. So revert all those back and then if you think SOME of them need entrance=yes IN ADDITION to barrier=entrance, then review each case individually for really being an enclosed area without other means to entry it. Thanks.

71306795 almost 6 years ago

Hi, thank you for adding the brand tags to objects in Bratislava.

But you also did more than that. Some changes from restaurant to fast_food are dubious. I could agree asian Panda "restaurants" should be fast foods, but then you should have added fast_food=cafeteria. But also the change of cuisine=asian to chinese is dubious. How do you know this particular Panda shops are members of the Panda Express chain you have added?
Also changes of shop=boutique to clothes is dubious, those different objects. You also converted all embassies to office=embassy, which is strictly forbidden on the amenity=embassy wiki page.

But the biggest problem is the changes of barrier=entrance to entrance=yes. Those are completely different objects, see osm.wiki/FR:Tag:barrier%3Dentrance and every one of those you touched that I looked at the change was wrong. Please refrain from automatic conversions, unless you have seen the place OR the conversion is explictly recommended on the wiki.

Please revert all the barrier=entrance and shop=boutique changes immediately. Thanks.

74478673 almost 6 years ago

Hi, I can't really hunt down what other specialized maps have for rules. I am mapping per the main wiki on osm.org. And you are right, this rule is written there. I rarely touch rails and am not familiar with the rules, I just wanted to fix the mess in Komarno where the tracks didn't match any aerial imagery. I hope at least I got that right.

Thanks for noticing and fixing the usage/service after me.

73876580 almost 6 years ago

Super, dik.

73876580 almost 6 years ago

Zdravim, nie je ta ulica Namestie osloboditelov uz otvorena (dobudovana)? Pisete, ze od 8.9.2019. Dakujem

69187197 almost 6 years ago

Zdravim, ked ste do relacie Pendolino (osm.org/relation/3782052) pridali useky trati az po Kosice, to vyzera dobre, ak naozaj taka vlakova linka existuje. Zmenili ste vsak len nazov relacie ale nepridali do nej ziadne stanice na slovenskom useku, takze takto je nefunkcna. Viete ich pridat? A prosim piste zmysluplnejsie popisy sad zmien ako len "upravy" a taktiez uvadzajte zdroj udajov. Dakujem.

74303259 almost 6 years ago

Ano, je mozne, ze boli body zastavky napojene na les.
Ma to vyzerat takto:
nastupiste (kde stoja ludia) : osm.org/node/1187547986
miesto zastavenia vozidla (na linii cesty): osm.org/node/1883177234

Äugl Arm v Rakusku mozno ma sirku potoka (podla fotiek), takze tam to problem nie je. Ale tie ramena na Slovenskej strane proste nesplnaju popis potoka, pozrite: osm.wiki/Tag:waterway%3Dstream

A natural=bay tiez vobec nedava zmysel, kedze tu nejde o morsky zaliv.

Tiez nie je nutne, aby rameno bolo zakreslene vodnou liniou, pozrite:
osm.wiki/Rivers
Staci jedna linia waterway pre danu rieku.

Ano tie nazvy ostrovov dajte len na jeden objekt, inak sa budu zobrazovat dvakrat, kedze teraz je to vlastne bod ostrova s nazvom *Ostrov a tiez plocha lesa s nazvom *Ostrov.

Tie zdroje nazvov treba uvadzat v popise sady zmien (znacka source), neviem kde sa to nastavuje v editore iD.
Kedze pravidlom OSM je overitelnost udajov, ktokolcvek pojde na to miesto a zisti, ze take nazvy tam nenajde, tak Vam to vymaze. Ak si v historii najde zdroj a on ho nema poruke, tak s vacsou pravdepodobnostou Vam to ponecha.

A viete poslat linku, kde je uvedena licencia tychto zdrojov, teda, ze sa z nich smu preberat udaje do OSM? Dakujem

70220129 almost 6 years ago

Zdravim, je tam aj waste_disposal a aj recyklacne kontajnery. Opravim.

73335708 almost 6 years ago

Hi, next time please add a description of the changeset (what you did/added) and add the source of the data.
Also please properly align imagery (aerail photos) to existing objects so that you place new objects properly. In this case you wrongly moved part of road at osm.org/node/4979560778 . You can even see at the rendered map how it is not straight now.
Thanks

74082586 almost 6 years ago

Hi, please do not add "stop" members with train stations into relations of type=railway. It is wrong, those relations do not represent public transport train lines. Add new route=train relations if you want to add a particular train line (service), with proper operator and train number. Thanks

59813733 almost 6 years ago

Hi, what is the source of these Hungarian names of churches in Bratislava? You wrote source=Oberpass-turbo which is a lie, that is just the source of the church buildings, but not of your added data. If you just manually translated the Slovak names to Hungarian, then that is wrong to add into OSM.

74157888 almost 6 years ago

Zdravim, to naozaj je usek ulice Sv. Stefana uz len pre cyklistov? Je to tak natrvalo? Preco su tam zakreslene dve cyklocesty vedla seba? A kadial teraz chodia autobusy? Dakujem

72707271 almost 6 years ago

Thanks for the answer. But you still did say what is the source of the names. And if the names aren't official, they shouldn't be put into the main 'name' tag (name:hu). Maybe use loc_name:hu if only some local Hungarian speaking citizens know those names?

73152505 almost 6 years ago

Dobry den, co prosim ste tu chceli upravit? Preco ste zmenili relaciu zeleznice (route=railway) na route=train, cize vlakovu linku? Aka je to vlakova linka 120, co ste vytvorili? Prosim opatrne a hlavne editor iD (ktory pouzivate) je nevhodny na upravy pokrocilych objektov ako su relacie. Prosim nedotykajte sa kolajnic, kym ho pouzivate. Dakujem.

72295953 almost 6 years ago

Hi, thanks for adding the maxspeeds on the railways in Slovakia, if they are real (I don't know). But you didn't need to destroy all the train relations (passenger lines) running along those railways. You removed all the touched segments from the relations. I'll have a bit of work fixing all that now:( Of course, maybe your editor iD did that improperly, but that is known, iD is bad for editing relations. So please when you touch railways or roads, use a proper editor like josm.openstreetmap.de . Thanks.

72707271 almost 6 years ago

Hi, why did you remove the trolleywire on road osm.org/way/240696203 ?

Also, the streets in Bratislava do not have Hungarian names. Where did you get those from? You have to provide the source in the changeset. If those are historical names, please move those from name:hu to old_name:hu .

Please use a more descriptive changeset description next time. "Streets of Bratislava" says nothing. It seems you added mostly Hungarian street names, which you could write in the description.

Thanks

74303259 almost 6 years ago

A Karloveske rameno ako natural=bay (zaliv, a dokonca len ako ciara) ? To je prosim kde taketo pouzitie popisane na wiki?
A tiez natural=stream (potok) ? To urcite potoky nie su.

Podla mna znacka na riecne rameno asi nie je, lebo asi nie je potrebna. Nazov ste mohli dat rovno na vodnu plochu ramena. Ak chcete, mozete nejaku zaviest, ale urcite nesmiete zneuzivat existujuce znacky, ktore uz maju iny definovany vyznam.