OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
107301258 almost 4 years ago

Hi,
I believe OR-224 should be a trunk road as this is a limited access roadway. The only at grade intersections for OR-224 are controlled by traffic lights. If you downgraded this due to it not being a dual carriageway, this is not necessarily a requirement for a road to be a trunk. See osm.wiki/Tag:highway=trunk

108439643 about 4 years ago

Hi Crestmont,

I see that you've removed some private roads in both this changeset and some of your past changesets. It generally is better practice to add the 'access=private' tag to these roads instead of removing them.

-archpdx
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/108439643

108394220 about 4 years ago

Sorry for the large bbox, this is probably due to me adding wikidata tags to Amtrak routes.

105654546 about 4 years ago

The DWG has placed a zero-hour block on them so hopefully they'll respond or address this issue:
osm.org/user_blocks/5221

97383716 about 4 years ago

Hi ScottCribs,
It looks like you changed the classification of Old Quacco Road to secondary in this changeset. In OpenStreetMap, secondary roadways are more important than tertiary, which doesn't seem to be the case in this scenario. I would suggest this roadway downgraded to tertiary.

-archpdx

107562826 about 4 years ago

Hi davegis,
It looks like you have changed Mosaic Circle to a secondary roadway in previous changesets. Is there a reason why this was changed? The previous classification used (highway=service) seems to be more correct in this scenario.

-archpdx

107236061 about 4 years ago

Hi,

As Allison noted, some of the roads under construction I've added within this bbox have been removed in this changeset, most likely accidentally. Readding these would be much appreciated.

-archpdx

105654546 about 4 years ago

Thanks for letting me know.

102737276 about 4 years ago

Hi davegis,
It looks like you've created duplicate features in this changeset, such as the Isle of Hope Pool Building. I've fixed this in a recent changeset.

-archpdx

101367083 about 4 years ago

Hi davegis,
It seems you've tagged what looks like a backyard putting green as a golf course (See osm.org/way/919599926). This could be tagged with golf=green + landuse=grass.

-archpdx

99646946 about 4 years ago

Hi davegis,
It looks like you've accidentally tagged a footway as a secondary road in this changeset. I've fixed this in a recent changeset.

-archpdx

106926513 about 4 years ago

Hi davegis,
It looks like you've accidentally altered the geometry of Memorial Stadium as well as creating duplicate POIs for features such as the football field, county works building, weight lifting center, and community center. Many of the tags used in these duplicate features weren't what best fits them, for example the fuel pump should not be labeled as a government office. I've fixed these issues in a recent changeset.

-archpdx

107521106 about 4 years ago

I don't think traffic islands would be appropriate here as there are signs for right-of-way directing traffic counter-clockwise around the island. The example you pointed out on the traffic island wiki page shows an island without any ROW signage. The wiki page for roundabouts (wiki.osm.org/Tag:junction=roundabout) shows that roundabouts could be used on nodes, which could be a compromise. It might fix your issue and directional tags could be added to the node.

107521106 about 4 years ago

Hi, thanks for your suggestion. I'll change the
three intersections that were changed to junction=circular ways.

107521106 about 4 years ago

Hi,

Welcome to OpenStreetMap! After looking at street-level imagery it seems that this intersection is a 'mini-roundabout'. Unlike roundabout ways, mini-roundabouts can be used on nodes and should also fix the navigational error you mentioned in your changeset comment. I've changed the traffic island node you created to this.

-archpdx

106075878 about 4 years ago

Thanks for pointing this out. I've removed this key from these buildings and I'll try to find a different way to represent these addresses. I originally thought of using addr:flats, but I wasn't sure if that would be correct. Ideally I don't want to create a bunch of ways/nodes, but I can if I have to once I have more free time.

105653882 about 4 years ago

Accidently requested changeset for review, forgot to uncheck

105587745 about 4 years ago

I see, I should have been more clear. The nodes I linked in my message above show the Central Beaverton and Denny Whitford/Raleigh West boundary crossing straight through the Kuni BMW and overlapping itself, which is what I thought was unintentional. I would fix it but I'm not sure where the updated boundaries should be.

105587745 about 4 years ago

Hi ,
Thank you for fixing this. However, I noticed you unintentionally dragged nodes on the Central Beaverton and Denny Whitford/Raleigh West boundary in this changeset. See:
osm.org/node/8783908261
osm.org/node/454364311

105555520 about 4 years ago

Error in changeset comment, downgraded Moxee to village, not city