Thank you for your contribution. You have drawn roads which overlap on themselves; this is raised as a data quality error as roads should not overlap. Please create individual roads for each segment instead of using the same road to go back and backtrack onto itself. Also, there are no intersection nodes with NW 12th St. There should be a node shared by intersecting roads so that they can be used for routing.

Cordial saludo Felipe Andrés. Por favor asegúrese en el futuro de chequear primero que los objetos que está añadiendo no existen ya, especialmente si está subiendo tracks de GPS. Adicionalmente, separe y cree intersecciones con las demás calles, de lo contrario no se podrá rutear por las mismas. Por ejemplo, el objeto osm.org/way/394421700/history está superimpuesto sobre calles previamente existentes. Gracias.

Cordial saludo. Por favor asegúrese de crear un nodo de intersección entre ciclorutas y la red vial, de lo contrario no se podrá rutear por ellas. Adicionalmente las intersecciones sin nodo son consideradas como erros por las diferentes herramientas de control de caldad de OSM. Gracias!

Thanks for the heads up, GerdP! My intention was to apply the prefix to the key instead of the value, but I probably clicked the wrong field in JOSM and started typing without noticing. I've applied a fix and committed it in changeset 37141121. Cheers.

Please note that Taft Street is *not* a dual carriageway as it has no physical separator. In addition, when splitting dual carriageways, ensure that you have connected intersecting roads to both one-ways and set oneway=yes on both directions. That was not done here.

Cordial saludo y gracias por su contribución. Por favor recuerde que los nombres deben ser entrados sin abreviaciones (Calle 102A y no Cll 102a).

Please be more careful when splitting dual carriageways. All ways connecting to SW 100th Ave south of Griffin Rd were left unconnected

Please be more careful when splitting dual carriageways, Golden Shoe Road northbound and southbound at SW 29th Place were left unconnected

Hola, bienvenido/a a OSM. La categoría highway=trunk se usa para vías de doble calzada. La carretera entre Caldas y Angelópolis es una carretera regional, por lo tanto la etiqueta trunk no le corresponde. Para mayor información puedes consultar la Guía para mapear en Colombia (osm.wiki/Gu%C3%ADa_para_mapear_en_Colombia). Cordial saludo.

Again, please be more careful and thorough when splitting dual carriageways. You've left both sides of North Park road as northbound only! Also, attributes like traffic lights at intersections must be propagated to the new/split road, and the lanes attribute must be adjusted (i.e. split).

Please be more careful and thorough when splitting dual carriageways. NW 56th Ave north- and south-bound segments were left unconnected, the entire undivided stretch between Sunrise Blvd and NW 19th St was left as one way, and many intersections were not extended to both directions. Thanks.

Oops, that should read of course: "while turning_circle has no non-transversable island". See osm.wiki/Tag:highway=turning_circle and osm.wiki/Tag:highway%3Dturning_loop

Hi, regarding the tags highway=turning_circle and highway=turning_loop in this commit, please note the difference: turning_loop has a non-transversable island, while turning_loop has no non-transversable island. It seems you've got these two mixed up since they were applied here opposite to their meaning. Thanks.

Hi there, regarding your changes in Plant City, FL, where you added separate ways for each lane (Alexander St & SR 39, for example). Please note a road should be mapped as a single way with attributes to denote that it has several lanes. You can use the lanes=* tag along with turn:lanes to map individual turning lanes. Note that for the latter case, you need to split the way and only assign the tag to the piece of way which has the turning lanes. See osm.wiki/Key:turn:lanes

Please be more careful next time with unfinished dual carriageways. You left a long segment of Lyons Road with oneway=yes without a corresponding way in the opposite direction.

Hi, as I mentioned before, roads which back-track on themselves keep coming up in data quality tools as overlapping. Please draw roads as single segments with other roads intersecting them, as opposed to having the same road backtrack and go in a different direction. If you have any questions, please feel free to reach out.

Gracias por las fotos, juanda097. La verdad no alcanzo a apreciar en ellas rieleve en el asfalto para categorizarlo como un "bump", pero si usted conoce el área eso es lo importante. En caso de no tener relieve, los categorizaría entonces como traffic_calming=rumble_strip. Gracias también por el link a la guía de mapeo en Colombia; la conozco :) Saludos

Cordial saludo. Quisiera confirmar que los cambios a los nodos de la Ruta 45 en la glorieta con la Ruta 40 en los que añade decenas de traffic_calming=bump son correctos? No conozco el area, pero me parece extraño que hubiera tantos policias acostados consecutivamente. De ser un error, por favor revierta sus cambios. Gracias de antemano.

Hola Iván, la etiqueta highway=motorway no aplica a vías en Colombia (véase osm.wiki/Gu%C3%ADa_para_mapear_en_Colombia#Etiquetas_de_rutas_en_Colombia). Estas vías tienen una definición específica restringida en OSM y bajo esa definición este tipo de vías no existen en Colombia (aún si se les llama coloquialmente "autopistas"). Por favor edite la prioridad de las vías con etiqueta highway=motorway de acuerdo a los criterios de red vial primaria, secundaria o terciaria según sea el caso.
Cordial saludo.

Hi Jan,
Thanks for the heads up! I've corrected the spelling on the key on the instances of destinaton:lanes returned by overpass turbo. As far as your remark is concerned, I didn't used destination:ref:lanes as the ref value on the destination roads does not match, e.g. I-595 East/West (which is what's on the lane markings/signs) is different from ref="I 595", and SR 84 is different from ref="FL 84"). According to the proposal on the wiki, "The key destination:ref=* should be used to specify the reference of the roads directly ahead as indicated on signposts, road markings or similar. The value of this key should be equal to the value of the key ref=* of these roads." Would you still recommend using destination:ref:lanes?