OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
51184055 about 8 years ago

Hello,
Someone who was adding population numbers has just been blocked. So is this a way to circumvent being blocked, or are you a genuine new editor?

Is the 2011 census data released under an open licence? Is there information about this?

51100923 about 8 years ago

So you're not really travelling and seeing what is really there, you're making undiscussed, mass edits from the comfort of your armchair. Do you think this is a good idea and that it is acceptable?

51004332 about 8 years ago

Welcome to OSM,

It is a common beginner's mistake to use the name tag as a description. Does the trig point really have a name 'Orton Hill Triangulation Pillar' on a name board at the location? If not then just don't use the name tag - many things don't have a name.

50979604 about 8 years ago

Hi,
It's good you removed the coastline tag. I expected you to respond to my comment, then we could try to help.

I'm still not sure what your source is. Would you tell me where did you get this information from please.

50979346 about 8 years ago

Welcome to OSM

I think you have tried to show a proposed new road. You haven't added a comment to the edit which would help make that clearer.

You have added what I think is the new road as coastline. This is very odd, is there any reason for this?

What is the source for this new road layout? Have you copied this from a plan or official source?

As it stands this edit needs changing then it could be useful, but we generally only add stuff to OSM that actually exists. Has this road been started or is it still just a proposal?

50707088 about 8 years ago

Hi,
Please add useful changeset comments. '.' really doesn't help understand what and why you are changing.

50680079 about 8 years ago

Hi,
Adding the designated= xxx is not widely using the UK. It is intended to show a specific legal restriction which often doesn't apply in the UK. In the UK it is more common to use designation=public_footpath or designation-public_bridleway. See osm.wiki/United_Kingdom_Tagging_Guidelines#Tagging_Access_Provisions

Mass editing of tags on a collection of objects (like this edit) is also frowned up as a mass-edit. We like these discussed in advance by the local community, in this case the talk-gb email list or talk-gb IRC channel would work. I suggest you would not get agreement for these changes.

Feel free to discuss here, but a wider audience would be better.

50630943 about 8 years ago

OK, starting out can be hard at first. I'll put the shop back where it was.

If you need help, please ask and I'll try to help.

50630915 about 8 years ago

I have reverted (undone) this edit. It looks like an experimental edit.

50630943 about 8 years ago

Welcome to OSM

You seem to have moved a shop in Tate Modern into the Thames. Did you realise that you were editing real, live data? Would you like any help sorting this out?

50540164 about 8 years ago

Looks much better, thanks.

50538503 about 8 years ago

Welcome to OSM

No problem, you didn't delete the point, a rather too hasty monitor did. You added the business and all looks well, except you added it to the road rather than over the building the business operates from. Please move it to the side of the road to where the business really is.

50539799 about 8 years ago

Welcome to OSM
You seem to have added the publishers twice. I suggest you delete one of the points.

Feel free to ask any questions.

50538503 about 8 years ago

I've reinstated the point. I needs moving over the top of the building that business is in, and then it will be a useful addition to the map.

If you have any questions, please ask.

50538503 about 8 years ago

Why was this deleted so quickly, with no comments?

50502202 about 8 years ago

Welcome to OSM
You seem to have deleted a lot of stuff, none of which looks like it should be deleted to me. Why have you deleted this stuff?

As a beginner you may not have realised you were deleting live data from the shared database.

I also notice you are using the Merkaartor editor. This is not widely used or supported anymore. You would probably be better using a different editor.

I will revert (undo) your edit to put the stuff back

If you have any questions please feel free to ask.

50487944 about 8 years ago

To add a house name I would always draw the outline of the house footprint, add a building tag and add the address tags. Don't use the name tag for a house name (common mistake) as that is for, say, a business name in a building. E.g a shop might have a building name as part of the address but the shop has a busness name in the name tag.

HTH

50487944 about 8 years ago

Welcome to OSM

Thanks for the detail.

We mark objects either by a single point or (better still) by drawing an area. When we place the single point we try to position it around the middle of the object. Adding a farm to the middle of a road is not how it is usually done. The aerial imagery shows a building to one side of the road, maybe it would be better to move the point there.

50456257 about 8 years ago

Welcome to OSM
I think you have got some wires crossed. You have added the details of a pub to a bus stop which is named after the pub nearby. Adding the pub, with its full details, would be good, but the pub details need removing from the bus stop. You can't buy a beer at a bus stop! :-)

50441510 about 8 years ago

Welcome to OSM
You seem to have changed the building name from 'Victoria House and Dorset House' to 'Mail Boxes Etc.'

This seems an unlikely name for a building. It is a common beginner's mistake to use the name tag for a description.

Would you like me to revert (undo) this change?