OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
149290075 over 1 year ago

I implore you to look through osm.wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct as this changeset (among others) seems non-conformant at first glance; see particularly its **Problematic usage** section.

While there might not be an explicit prohibition on an ad-hoc addition of an easily computable tag, adding (mechanically or otherwise) trivially computable tags tends to go against OSM philosophy, and there really should be discussion before changing the last modified date of thousands of objects, as they suddenly look like they were recently verified; please see https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZrvcVAPdaWI at about 9 minutes in.

149290075 over 1 year ago

Could you please provide a link for where the consensus for this seemingly mechanical edit (which lacks mechanical edit tags and wasn't created with a separate mechanical edit account) was reached?

I've removed addr:state tags during some of my manual editing per past wiki guidance, but if there's consensus for adding the tag then I'll change my behavior.

149290075 over 1 year ago

Given that these are deep inside the state's boundary, is adding the state really desireable?

146214729 over 1 year ago

Changeset description should've been:

A couple of hydrants and a link road and some lighting and poles from survey along Main Street. Other lighting and poles, all trees, and realignments from imagery.

145780258 over 1 year ago

bollards should be away from road.

144707542 over 1 year ago

Corrected in changeset 145346538.

144707542 over 1 year ago

Similarly with 165th just south of Main Street. An old note I had mentioned a stop sign there. Might've been too old.

144707542 over 1 year ago

The stops I placed on 166th at NE 4th are likely inaccurate with outdated imagery. If so then the nodes should perhaps have a note= or other tag to avoid retagging.

143447590 over 1 year ago

from survey, not imagery; trees and other street lamps from imagery.

143117364 almost 2 years ago

takeover tag also from survey; probably should split close to intersections.

141574748 almost 2 years ago

incomplete

136641151 almost 2 years ago

osm.org/changeset/140623612

140413241 almost 2 years ago

osm.org/user/goldfndr/traces/9716161

I've since confirmed trace and this map update were good.

136641151 almost 2 years ago

The change of the yield location is confusing. With node 1713572090 tagged as give_way instead of node 2532291172, it looks like drivers yield only after they've already driven partway into Southcenter Parkway instead of at the triangles painted on the link road prior to the intersection.

135172523 over 2 years ago

Got a bit carried away here. Trees from imagery, most objects from previous notes.

134994810 over 2 years ago

street lamps, street cabinets, trees, hydrant from imagery

133771202 over 2 years ago

Location of gate at south of side road is confirmed. There's also a corresponding gate to the north in the obvious location.

41544634 over 2 years ago

Thank you for the improvements over my poor approximations.

131482408 over 2 years ago

A more intuitive changeset comment would be something like:

Corrected shop=clothing to shop=clothes

131293835 over 2 years ago

Changed again, close to how it was. Need to survey again.