Logoya OpenStreetMapê OpenStreetMap

New validation rule: Suspicious addr:state value

Ji alî mtmail ve di 31 July 2025 de bi English hatiye nivîsîn.

The Nominatim QA tool added a new layer “Suspicious addr:state value”

  • If addr:state is the same addr:province. Depending on country addr:province might not be needed
  • If addr:state is the same as the country code
  • if addr:state is the same as the country name (in any language)

https://nominatim.org/qa/#map=3.52/34.84/5.81&layer=addr_state_not_country

The layer is updated every day.

Give it a go. But not USA and Canada because I was too eager and made many edits today already.

Email icon Bluesky Icon Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Mastodon Icon Telegram Icon X Icon

Discussion

Şîroveya Glassman a 1 August 2025 saet 02:37

Thanks for fixing those in Canada. I could say something about becoming the 51st state, but who needs that xxx

Şîroveya CjMalone a 1 August 2025 saet 08:59

I could say something about interoperability, but who needs that.

Şîroveya mtmail a 10 August 2025 saet 18:52

The validation might need a couple of exceptions:

Algeria and Argentina don’t seem to have consensus if addr:province or addr:state should be used in address tags. Both countries’ name their subdivisions province (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Provinces_of_Algeria , https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Provinces_of_Argentina).

Mexico has a state called Mexico https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_of_Mexico

Ji bo ku tu şîroveyek binivîsî Têkeve