robert's Comments
Changeset | Kengê | Şîrove |
---|---|---|
129966231 | berî zêdetirî 2 salan | That's all of them that are exceedingly dump then. Using fuzzy heuristics to determine routability between ways will not work as well as you appear to think it will - making it able to "jump" between apparently unrelated ways would require mappers to go back through the whole of OSM putting in explicit barriers (walls etc.) where we don't want this to be possible. Not going to happen. |
129966231 | berî zêdetirî 2 salan | There is no information you have conveyed to the OSM data model that could let it know that it's possible to traverse from that footway to Ashmole Street directly. Unless you're about to rewrite the last 20 years of routing technology for us around vague proximity of ways to each other denoting traversability, in OSM we have to work to the "limitations" of what we currently have, and adding sidewalks in the fashion is going to lead to weird routing results for users without really adding much of any use. |
129966231 | berî zêdetirî 2 salan | The problem with doing separate ways for sidewalks is it screws up routing: https://gist.github.com/risicle/c523638c7768b1c3292e8c7b07aa7563 |
76466311 | berî zêdetirî 5 salan | Are you sure Cobbets Farm isn't actually spelt with two "t"s, as in OS Locator? https://ris.dev.openstreetmap.org/oslmusicalchairs/map?osl_id=189443 |
75046427 | hema bêje berî 6 salan | Why did you get rid of the name Lapworth Court in this edit? It broke a match with OS Locator: https://ris.dev.openstreetmap.org/oslmusicalchairs/map?osl_id=988326 |
73266445 | hema bêje berî 6 salan | So if this is all Mop End Lane, what is Horsemoor Lane? https://ris.dev.openstreetmap.org/oslmusicalchairs/map?osl_id=391222 |
71676657 | teqrîben berî 6 salan | Sorry, I reverted this changeset with my changeset osm.org/changeset/71719440 as it was too destructive, leaving a large gap in Wood Lane and deleting roads like Danette Gardens entirely. |
71198588 | teqrîben berî 6 salan | Some people use mapillary and quite like it. |
71198588 | teqrîben berî 6 salan | We really shouldn't use other maps as our sources due to copyright concerns - so we tend to go by what signs say IRL. |
71198588 | teqrîben berî 6 salan | Are you _sure_ it's ClarAnce Gardens? OS Locator seems to disagree https://ris.dev.openstreetmap.org/oslmusicalchairs/map?osl_id=181411 |
68564129 | teqrîben berî 6 salan | Did you mean to remove the name "Malham Close" in this edit? It broke a match against OS Locator: https://ris.dev.openstreetmap.org/oslmusicalchairs/map?osl_id=477237 |
68813409 | teqrîben berî 6 salan | I have a feeling you've overwritten "Ryehill Close" with the name "Grey Towers Drive" here, breaking a match against OS Locator: https://ris.dev.openstreetmap.org/oslmusicalchairs/map?osl_id=646192 |
68539723 | teqrîben berî 6 salan | I'll add a not:name tag to it in the hopes nobody will come and change it back (it's what's in OS Locator: https://ris.dev.openstreetmap.org/oslmusicalchairs/map?osl_id=979851) |
68766413 | teqrîben berî 6 salan | Oops - did you remove the highway= tag from "Sterndale Road" in this changeset? https://ris.dev.openstreetmap.org/oslmusicalchairs/map?osl_id=710987 |
68454194 | teqrîben berî 6 salan | Did "University Road" get renamed? https://ris.dev.openstreetmap.org/oslmusicalchairs/map?osl_id=774415 If so, it might be nice to add it as old_name or alt_name for records. |
70257670 | teqrîben berî 6 salan | You deleted "Wessex Court" in this edit didn't add the name back to the replacement way. This has broken a match against OS Locator: https://ris.dev.openstreetmap.org/oslmusicalchairs/map?osl_id=957117 |
68766325 | berî zêdetirî 6 salan | If you're sure this is Lacey Green and not Lacy Green (https://ris.dev.openstreetmap.org/oslmusicalchairs/map?osl_id=935059), should probably add a not:name= tag to mark it so |
68596125 | berî zêdetirî 6 salan | Did you mean to delete "Burlington Close" in this edit? It broke a match against OS Locator: https://ris.dev.openstreetmap.org/oslmusicalchairs/map?osl_id=129946 |
68696017 | berî zêdetirî 6 salan | Good edit - welcome to OpenStreetMap! |
68123074 | berî zêdetirî 6 salan | But why did you delete Newhaven Court in the process? It has broken a match against OS Locator https://ris.dev.openstreetmap.org/oslmusicalchairs/map?osl_id=536863 - please do not do such destructive things. |