OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
142163842 almost 2 years ago

Rather than mapping trees as small circles, you should use nodes/points to map the trees.

142110214 almost 2 years ago

'This changeset has been reverted. Access tags should be used instead of deleting the ways, even if they are private property. You can read more about why "private" features should not be deleted here:

osm.wiki/Why_we_won%27t_delete_roads_on_private_property'

osm.org/changeset/142120543

142110172 almost 2 years ago

'This changeset has been reverted. Access tags should be used instead of deleting the ways, even if they are private property. You can read more about why "private" features should not be deleted here:

osm.wiki/Why_we_won%27t_delete_roads_on_private_property'

osm.org/changeset/142120543

142120246 almost 2 years ago

'This changeset has been reverted. Access tags should be used instead of deleting the ways, even if they are private property. You can read more about why "private" features should not be deleted here:

osm.wiki/Why_we_won%27t_delete_roads_on_private_property'

osm.org/changeset/142120498

142119901 almost 2 years ago

'This changeset has been reverted. Access tags should be used instead of deleting the ways, even if they are private property. You can read more about why "private" features should not be deleted here:

osm.wiki/Why_we_won%27t_delete_roads_on_private_property'

osm.org/changeset/142120498

141973106 almost 2 years ago

Features should not be named with descriptive tags, such as the cartpath. Also, be sure you are utilizing the correct tags.

141796581 almost 2 years ago

Is there a reason you didn't continue the golfcart path as a bridge over the river/stream/water?

141795840 almost 2 years ago

A couple things:
1) The landcovers should not partially overlap.
2) Features should not be deleted and readded. They should be adjusted.

You can read more here:
osm.wiki/Tag:leisure%3Dgolf_course#:~:text=Overlapping%20green/fairway/rough%20polygons%20(see%20graphic%20below).

I have gone ahead and cleaned up the golf course to address the pitfalls.

141794975 almost 2 years ago

Crap. That was unintentional. I was trying to get a wikipedia tag, but ID removed the wikidata tag.

I'll get it readded. They didn't have a wiki page, so I tried to create one, but it is still sitting in review, so the wikipedia tag isn't valid, most likely.

141755521 almost 2 years ago

Also split up underpasses so maxheight=* tags can be applied appropriately in StreetComplete.

141692446 almost 2 years ago

Sounds like you are mapping for the renderer, rather than mapping to ensure good data for the map overall. The OSM database does not know which is the "top layer" for landcover. In these cases. The fairway does not exist where the putting green is. Additionally, the fairway does not exist as a sharp triangle into the green.

ID will not directly report an issue, but areas should still not overlap, especially in the manner shown. They should either touch and not overlap, or the putting green should be wholly within the fairway. The fairway is not a sharp triangle into the putting green or a random square into it.

The land and area is mutually exclusive. It should be either a putting green or a fairway, but the small triangles and random areas where the fairways go into the green are not correct. Not to mention, it comes across sloppy since it is easier to just end an area where it looks right for a renderer (golf game), rether than doing it correctly.

Do not map for the renderer. I have politely advised you to stop partially overlapping landcover. If you have any questions on how to map golf courses correctly and in high quality, I suggest you reach out to User Seaside83.

Openstreetmap.org/user/Seaside83

141694100 almost 2 years ago

Please remove the speed limits you added to nodes and instead add them to the road on the ways. You may need to break up the ways into smaller pieces such that the way ends whenever the speed limit changes.

141694100 almost 2 years ago

That is not how you add speed limits. Speed limits are added to the ways, not the nodes.

osm.wiki/Key:maxspeed#:~:text=The%20maxspeed%3D*%20tag%20is%20used%20on%20ways

141691259 almost 2 years ago

Areas should not overlap, as has been done on the fairway and green. They should either not overlap, or the smaller area (green) should be wholly within the larger area.

Partial overlaps throw validation errors. I have resolved this. Please be cognizant of this in future edits.

141692446 almost 2 years ago

Areas should not overlap, as has been done on the fairway and green. They should either not overlap, or the smaller area (green) should be wholly within the larger area.

Partial overlaps throw validation errors. I have resolved this. Please be cognizant of this in future edits.

141541281 almost 2 years ago

That node was for the apartment complex, not the hostel. The wrong tag was used. I have reverted this and corrected it.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/141541281

141569312 almost 2 years ago

Duplicated features were removed

141487868 almost 2 years ago

Are all these road closures temporary or permanent?

70094787 almost 2 years ago

Houses should not be named "House". Instead they should get the tag "building=house"

141487970 almost 2 years ago

I have mentioned this before.... Do NOT "lollipop" areas to create "holes". Multi-polygon relations should be used instead. I have cleaned it up for you.