OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
68599642 over 6 years ago

Hi VinceJesse. See my previous message. More of the same. Mostly remapping and realigning needed. Many buildings were oversized by mapping the shadow on the ground as part of the building.
Best regards

68602476 over 6 years ago

Hi, I am reviewing this changeset because according to your profile you are a new mapper. In JOSM I ran the validation tool and noticed next unsolved issues ( a validators job to solve them)
19 warning, most of them connections between highway to buildings. crossing buildings and highways
11 unsquared buildings and 4 overlapping areas.
Also a lot of buildings were poor mapped ( oversized or inaccurate or mapped a cluster of buildings as 1.)
I will correct these. Please stick to mapping till you have enough expericene to become a validator.
This webpage shows your mappings
https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=68602476
This one after I adjusted them
https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=69001633
Thanks for- and keep mapping

68601144 over 6 years ago

Hi Robin. Je hebt hier niet echt je best op gedaan om deze task goed te mappen. Ik heb dat dan maar voor je gedaan. ( sorry voor mijn sarcasme, maar ik ben uren bezig de puinhoop van jullie (Mapatlon?) te corrigeren.

68597431 over 6 years ago

Hello gurensch. I ran into an area which you have validated. I noticed that you are a novice mapper and already qualified to validate. How is that possible? Normal procedure is that a mapper need to have a serious expertise in mapping before he/she might become a validator who can validate tasks for which a validator status is required.
In this changeset you did not square buildings, despite you modified them.
take a look to this webpage
https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=68597431
I reviewed a number of your validations and must conclude your work does not comply with the standards , Validators worthy. Please restrict yourself to mapping work till you have enough experience.
Best regards

68365499 over 6 years ago

Hi AgagoSilva. Thanks for mapping in this dense area. A remark. As you can read in the instructions we ought to correct wrongly mapped buildings. quote "Please improve existing incorrectly mapped elements by moving and adjusting, rather than deleting, if they do not line up with the imagery."
You also adjusted hardly any building. see your mappings on this page
https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=68365499
And left a big quantity of buildings unsquared.
I am goiing to invalidate this task
Would you be so kind to review this task again and correct the mappings ?
Best regards and please keep mapping

68394817 over 6 years ago

Hello Emory, Thanks for mapping in this dense area. A request. Map buildings just as building=yes (as per instructions). Do not name a building like here with name=a. Even building level .This makes no sense and will be deleted.
And last, Please square each rectangular building with the S key
Best regards and keep mapping

68639285 over 6 years ago

Hello Furbs. Thanks for mapping in this dense area. A request. Please tag next time all rectangular buildings with the S key. You overlooked about 50 buildings.
best regards and keep mapping.

68709712 over 6 years ago

Hello maawoo Thanks for mapping here.
A request. Please square each rectangular building after you have mapped it. Use the S key in iDeditor. Take care not to overlap buildings.
Best regards and keep mapping.

68775216 over 6 years ago

Hello Agathe. Thanks for mapping here.
A request. Please square each rectangular building after you have mapped it. Use the S key in iDeditor. Take care not to overlap buildings.
Best regards and keep mapping.

68745819 over 6 years ago

Hi DavinceK
I've noticed the mappings of a lot of paths on this (and other) changesets.
Very detailed and must cost you a lot of time.
Nothing wrong with these mappings, but realize that, for the purpose of this project, it is important to concentrate on mapping of buildings and highways which connect to hamlets, villages and other highways.
isolated highways (paths and tracks which do not lead to houses etc) are not important here
Best regards

68763931 over 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping. A request.
Please square all ( ! )rectangular buildings with the S key in iD editor after mapping each one.
Best regards and keep mapping

68761004 over 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping. A request.
Please square all ( ! )rectangular buildings with the S key in iD editor after mapping each one.
Best regards and keep mapping

68371953 over 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping. A request.
Please square all rectangular buildings with the S key in iD editor after mapping each one.
Best regards and keep mapping

68677614 over 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping. A request.
Please square all rectangular buildings with the S key in iD editor after mapping each one.
Best regards and keep mapping

68682253 over 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping. A request.
Please square all rectangular buildings with the S key in iD editor after mapping each one.
Best regards and keep mapping

68769955 over 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping. A request.
Please square all rectangular buildings with the S key in iD editor after mapping each one.
Best regards and keep mapping

68636391 over 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping here.
A request. Please check the East African Highways WIKI to make a good choice how to tag highways here,
osm.wiki/East_Africa_Tagging_Guidelines

osm.wiki/User:Bgirardot/West_African_HOT_Mapping_Tips
Best regards and keep mapping.
(mapping a track in farmland as highway-secondary is not a good choicd)

68763943 over 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping here.
A request. Please check the East African Highways WIKI to make a good choice how to tag highways here,
osm.wiki/East_Africa_Tagging_Guidelines

osm.wiki/User:Bgirardot/West_African_HOT_Mapping_Tips
Best regards and keep mapping.

68683777 over 6 years ago

Hello
Thanks for mapping here.
Please check the Highway wiki how to map highways in East Africa the tag residential is restricted to urban areas.

osm.wiki/East_Africa_Tagging_Guidelines

osm.wiki/User:Bgirardot/West_African_HOT_Mapping_Tips

Thanks and keep mapping

68774737 over 6 years ago

Hi Katrina, Thanks for mapping here.
I noticed that you map a track with on the end tags Highway=crossing and tag crossing=unmarked. No need to do that. Just leave the track where and as it ends. See similar situations mapped by others

Best regards and keep mapping