OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
65328296 over 6 years ago

Hello, Thanks for mapping here. I review tasks in order to validate them.
A remark. Please review the India highway wiki
osm.wiki/India:Roads
You tag highways in the middle of nowhere as secondary highways and unclassified
Best for thoroughgoing is unclassified. otherwise track (in the fields)
Additionally you don't need to name tag highways.
But, most important. The goal is to map type unclassified highways, which connect hamlets, villages etc.
I corrected them.

65506514 over 6 years ago

HI, Thanks for your response. No need to change. I did it during validating
Best regards

65506514 over 6 years ago

Hi Gramnation. Thanks for mapping.
I am reviewing this task for validating.
A remark. Please tag all highways which you mapped. You did not tag 5 highways. Please pay attention to that.
Best regards

65281589 over 6 years ago

Hi Alvarozfranco, Thanks for mapping on this project. I review this work to validate tasks.
A remark. When you map highways which continues over the edge of your task, please map them a bit over the edge so other mappers can continue with mapping of that highway.
Best regards

65180418 over 6 years ago

Hi Renee, Thanks for mapping on this project. I am reviewing tasks for validations
A remark.
This is a road only project. No need to map buildings. Please stick to the highways.
Another point about buildings. You hardly squared buildings which you have mapped here. Please use the S key to square buildings you have mapped ( not the round ones of course)
Something odd. You have mapped a number of buildings with a 5th node which you placed in the centre of the building. By accident? Please take another look to this website to improve your mapping skills
https://learnosm.org/en/hot-tips/tracing-rectangular-buildings/
Thanks and best regards

64593276 over 6 years ago

Hi again. Please take a look to this webpage
https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=65501614
Here you can see your mappings and the adjustments which has to be made
Best regards

64593276 over 6 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping. I am reviewing tasks to validate them. A few remarks.
1 When you map a highway=unclassified, it is not necessary to add the tag name=unclassified. I deleted these tags.
2. be sure to connect nodes of crossing highways to each other (you missed a lot)
3 don't map 2 different kinds of highways on the same place. Connect them with the nodes.
4 don't map isolated pieces of highway in the fields. try to connect them to other highways.
5 Unclassified highways in agriculture areas without connections to residential areas are preferably to be tagged as track
6 When mapping highways which continue over the edge of your task, pleas map them over the edge, so another mapper find them on the adjacent task
7, When a highway crosses a waterway, please map a bridge or a ford.
Thank you and best regards
ps. you are editing in JOSM. Why don't you use the Validating tool. Many of the points I mentioned will be reported directly and can be corrected by yourself
even the 'inline validating" map paint style is very helpful to avoid errors

64673715 over 6 years ago

Hello, Thanks for mapping on this project. I am reviewing tasks and have a remark.
When you map bridges please add 'layer=1'to the tag. (otherwise water and bridge seems to be on the same level.
Best regards

35165192 over 6 years ago

Hello,Thank you for mapping. I am reviewing tasks and have a remark. When you map bridges, please add 'layer=1'to the tags. (otherwise water and highway are on the same level)
Best regards

64722598 over 6 years ago

Hi Venkanna37. I am reviewing this task for validation. You tag highways her (in empty area) as highway=service. This tag is suitable for entrees to gasfilling stations, closed factory roads etc, Please look at the India Highway wiki.
Thanks for mapping

65095900 over 6 years ago

Hi, another point. I see that you mapped a number of objects, (waterways etc ) twice.
No idea how you manage that, but please pay attention to that.
You also don't connect always nodes of a waterway to each other. (they must snap, a small gap is not allowed)
Best regards

65095900 over 6 years ago

Hello, I review mapped tasks and have a remark. Please map residential areas as
landuse=residential instead of place=village
Thank you for mapping

63310110 over 6 years ago

Thank you for mapping here. Please pay more attention how to map a bridge over a waterway. Please take a look on this wiki to improve your mappings
osm.wiki/Key:bridge
thanks and best regards

65478350 over 6 years ago

Hi, I am reviewing tasks and saw your mappings. Thanks for mapping here. A few remarks.
When a highway crosses a river, take a good look how, when it is a bridge, tag that piece of road as bridge, and layer=1. (otherwise the water is on same level as bridge) In other cases it might be a Ford.
Next. try to continue highways along a visible track. and try to connect them to other highways
Thanks

64987543 over 6 years ago

Hello. I am reviewing tasks done by mappers. A remark. Please tag an object after mapping it. Here you did not mark highways.
Thanks for contributing to this project

64858678 over 6 years ago

Hello Fahim.
I am reviewing this task. Please use highway=residential in urban areas, not as a through going highway. Highways ending in agricultural areas without houses should better tagged as track
Thanks for mapping.

64890628 over 6 years ago

Hello Yasin, I am reviewing this task and have a remark.
When a waterway crossed a highway with a bridge (highway) don't add a layer=-1 on a piece waterway. The bridge tag layer=1 is sufficient. Thanks for mapping

64673616 over 6 years ago

Hi, I am reviewing tasks in this project. A few remarks
1. When mapping a bridge, please add layer=1 (otherwise road and waterway are on same level)
2. Check India Highway tag. Use serviceway only for access to industrial estates, etc. not in urban areas.
Thanks for mapping
Best regards

64841099 over 6 years ago

Hi, I am reviewing taks and have a few remarks on your mappings.
1. When tagging a bridge, add tag layer=1
2. don't use the generic tag highway=road. This is a tag which has to be avoided because this is an old tag and obsolete. Please follow the India Highway tag page
Thanks for your effords and keep mapping
Best regards

63412153 over 6 years ago

Hallo Sylvia, Tijdens het controleren van gemapte gebouwen zag ik dat je heel veel (bijna allemaal? ) gebouwen gemapt heb maar niet goed vierkant gemaakt met de S toets in ID. Op het zicht lijkt het goed, maar is het niet helemaal. Gebouwen zijn meestal (muv ronde hutten en gebouwen) rechthoekig met rechte hoeken. Zo moeten ze ook gemapt worden. (dit is oa een kwaliteits punt, waar momenteel veel aandacht aan wordt gegeven.) Graag de volgende keer aandacht aan besteden. Bedankt voor het mappen. Ga zo door.