Retired Account's Comments
Changeset | Noiz | Iruzkina |
---|---|---|
125373826 | duela ia 3 urte | @Woazboat
The ways being tagged meets your definition.
|
125373826 | duela ia 3 urte | If simply deleting off all custom tags across several changesets #125373826, #125428168, #125428245 in the middle of an active dispute does not consititute banning, without seeing logical rationale or procedures illustrates a experienced mapper, I am humbled by how such actions can be taken and further justified. |
125373826 | duela ia 3 urte | With your response, it will mean that the official policy should change to...
|
125373826 | duela ia 3 urte | Defines "driveway is a minor service road providing access from the highway to an offstreet area used for driving, servicing, parking, or otherwise accommodating motor vehicles", which can include minor roads linking to parking aisles, or minor roads linking to other minor roads. Your statement saying it is no meaning is false. Trying to equate tag with meaning to h=oefotprkf is an instance of straw man argument. Please try something better. |
125373826 | duela ia 3 urte | Your stance and actions are unreasonable, and contradicts the infobox stating the following...
Your actions, on contrast, is contradicting that. |
125373826 | duela ia 3 urte | "To define a service way in more detail, see service=*." You are missing the point stated above by saying it provides no specific meaning. If we apply this logic to service=driveway, I can similar say that that particular tag also provides no specific meaning. Your logic is not valid. |
125373826 | duela ia 3 urte | As stated, there is no banned tags and what you or your community perceives as nonsense does not apply beyond your community. Further, you have no valid justification for any such change, and are in no position to dictate what mappers use. |
125373826 | duela ia 3 urte | Your change will be reverted as you are not able to provide any substantiation of your stand. |
125373826 | duela ia 3 urte | As a sidenote, this change also illustrates that whatever you have wrote as your values do not match the action seen here. |
125373826 | duela ia 3 urte | This changeset is an automated edit, solely based on your personal perception that this is nonsense. The Wiki page itself is meant to document what is the tag meant to be. Woodpeck comment is regarding the removal of the Wiki page (which it is up to the discretion of the Wiki Administrators), but it should not stop mappers doing the actual mapping from mapping how they intend to (whether it is in the area of using a custom tag). You are performing wilful data removal away by attempting to remove minor service road classification. The intention for the mapping here is to ensure all minor service roads are classified using service=* and have an approporiate minor service road type. In any case, there is no banned features and this change should be reverted. |
123718576 | duela 3 urte inguru | Fixed in osm.org/changeset/123855979 |
119835169 | duela 3 urte baino gehiago | This change incorrect changes a building:part to become a building way, and duplicates the building. The previous tagging is correct.
|
119435110 | duela 3 urte baino gehiago | This change incorrectly removes the carpark building just for "fixing osmose" error. |
118829522 | duela 3 urte baino gehiago | This change violates the "Name is the name only" rule. osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only |
118843685 | duela 3 urte baino gehiago | This change violates the "Name is the name only" rule. osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only |
118843717 | duela 3 urte baino gehiago | This change violates the "Name is the name only" rule. osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only |
118843743 | duela 3 urte baino gehiago | This change violates the "Name is the name only" rule. osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only |
118843899 | duela 3 urte baino gehiago | This change violates the "Name is the name only" rule. osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only |
115163178 | duela 3 urte baino gehiago | Sega --> Lawson? |
110498265 | duela ia 4 urte | Hi,
|