OpenStreetMap
how to map usage of university buildings
Diposkan oleh Sanderd17 pada 10 November 2010 dalam EnglishIf you look at osm.org/?lat=50.86384&lon=4.67707&zoom=17&layers=M , you see that the university buildings have references. These are mapped as names since these are used on all the signs. But I also want to map the use of the building.
e.g. building B 200 is the mathematics building, A 200 is informatics ...
This doesn't have to appear on the map (it would make the map unreadable anyway) but I like to have it in the database. The only problem is that I can't find an appropriate tag for it. I don't even have enough inspiration to think of a tag myself.
Discussion
Ulasan Pink Duck terhadap 10 November 2010 pada 13:59
You could use addr:housename for the taught subject and addr:housenumber for the building identifier, then use the name tag to display the building code by default.
Ulasan Sanderd17 terhadap 10 November 2010 pada 14:04
so e.g.
addr:housename=Departement Wiskunde
addr:housename_en=Department of Mathematics
addr:housenumber=200 B
name=200 B
do you mean this? it looks good to me.
Ulasan EdLoach terhadap 10 November 2010 pada 14:14
Or instead of building=yes, building=mathematics_faculty (or whatever).
Ulasan Sanderd17 terhadap 10 November 2010 pada 14:25
well, at the key:building page in the wiki, they say thee building= is common. I don't think that "mathematics_faculty" is a type of building typology. I prefer to use a tag that doesn't collide with other used tags.
Ulasan Sanderd17 terhadap 10 November 2010 pada 14:26
sorry, html screwed up my post. It's unreadable in that way, I'll reformat it here:
well, at the key:building page in the wiki, they say the building="building_typlology" is common. I don't think that "mathematics_faculty" is a type of building typology. I prefer to use a tag that doesn't collide with other used tags.
Ulasan !i! terhadap 10 November 2010 pada 17:05
Hmm I always thought about a relation to stitch all university buildings together and highlight them in a map style.
osm.wiki/Relations/Proposed/Site
unfortunatly I lack of time :(
Ulasan Minh Nguyen terhadap 10 November 2010 pada 18:41
building=yes
operator=Departement Wiskunde
operator:en=Department of Mathematics
Ulasan SamatJain terhadap 10 November 2010 pada 21:17
> building=yes
>operator=Departement Wiskunde
> operator:en=Department of Mathematics
I feel this is misleading… in universities in the USA, at least, the "operator" of the building is the university, and the department just a tenant.
I like the proposal in the first comment, using addr:housename.
Ulasan compdude terhadap 11 November 2010 pada 03:59
I know this isn't really related to your post but I noticed some areas around the university that are marked with the tag landuse=forest. According to the wiki, this tag should be used only for forests that are managed (ie owned by a logging company). Obviously these forests don't appear to be big enough to be owned by a logging company, so shouldn't they be marked as natural=wood?
Ulasan SamatJain terhadap 11 November 2010 pada 05:42
@compdude: But, a forest on university land *is* managed—by the university.
Ulasan Sanderd17 terhadap 11 November 2010 pada 09:55
so the addr:housename tag it is.
Should I put this on the wiki for other university, school or compagny buildings?
@compdude, I don't know it these are managed. In Belium, every piece of ground is managed by someone, if they had permission to put a building on it, they would. So I guess most woods are forests but I can be wrong.
Ulasan jnsc terhadap 11 November 2010 pada 16:25
you could have a look here : osm.org/?lat=46.51947&lon=6.56942&zoom=16&layers=M
and
http://plan.epfl.ch/
Ulasan Vclaw terhadap 11 November 2010 pada 16:57
I don't think the "addr:housename" tag (or the "name" tag) is correct for this. Those tags are for the name of the building, which is not necessarily the same as the name of the department based in that building.
I would suggest using a different tag, eg "department", or maybe "operator:department"
Though at the universities I'm familiar with, most buildings are used by several different departments anyway.
Also, if the building has a reference, eg a letter and number, I think that should be tagged as "ref", as its not really a name.
Ulasan Kevin Steinhardt terhadap 11 November 2010 pada 18:49
I would have put the building numbers as ref=* and 'Department of Whatever' as name=Department of Whatever (or name:en=Department of Whatever)
Ulasan Sanderd17 terhadap 12 November 2010 pada 09:03
the name=Department X isn't good. The name should be the word by which everyone calls it (official and non-official sources). In this case the letter A, B ... or the complete ref: 200 A, 200 B...
I'm willing to duplicate that in a ref=... tag, but It's already in the addr:housenumber and in the name tag. so creating an extra ref tag is totally unnecessary.
maybe the addr:housename tag isn't correct. I do find the operator:department good, but there are buildings who have other usages as well. Like computer classes or labs. They don't belong to a department, but do have a name like "PC-classes".
Ulasan marscot terhadap 12 November 2010 pada 15:33
I would use
building=yes
Building:use=School or what ever it is
Building:name=A200 or what ever
building:height=10m
building:roof=
now thats the building done but the building can have more than one address one side could be main street the other back street thats why you should tag a node inside with address details and not on the building tags