archpdx's Comments
Changeset | When | Comment |
---|---|---|
151036130 | about 1 year ago | The same can be said for almost every street in the US, spelling out street names is just one of OSM's conventions. This allows for data consumers such as renderers and routers to choose whether or not to abbreviate them. |
151036130 | about 1 year ago | Hi,
|
150898942 | about 1 year ago | amenity=hospital should only be used for hospital grounds, I would use building=hospital for the buildings |
149588106 | over 1 year ago | Hi and welcome to OpenStreetMap! Thanks for mapping these houses/addresses. Quick tip: you can square corners of a building by pressing 'q' when selecting it. |
149712721 | over 1 year ago | Hi and welcome to OpenStreetMap! Thanks for mapping these houses. Please note however that the name field isn't used to describe features in OSM (see osm.wiki/Names#Names_are_not_for_descriptions). |
148075727 | over 1 year ago | Just because it doesn't exist on USGS doesn't mean this isn't a real place name. West Hazel Dell is one of the neighborhood associations in Clark County, all of which were imported from CCGIS. |
148075580 | over 1 year ago | In OSM, we only map current features, not places from 1956. If you're interested in mapping historical places like these, I recommend taking a look at https://openhistoricalmap.org/ |
147872000 | over 1 year ago | As noted on the OSM Wiki, `place=locality` is used in OSM for named places without a population, which Happy Valley definitely is not. (osm.wiki/Tag:place%3Dlocality) |
147872415 | over 1 year ago | Hi, I noticed you changed Camas from a town to a suburb. As noted on the OSM Wiki "OSM's usage of 'suburb' is different than that used by North American English, where a suburb is "an area, often residential, outside of a central city". Often these suburbs are distinct settlements and will be tagged as place=village, place=town, or place=city, depending on factors such as population."
In other words, incorporated places like Camas should be classified as a city/town/village in OSM whilst suburb/quarter/neighborhood are used for neighborhoods within these incorporated places or unincorporated places such as CDPs. |
147946454 | over 1 year ago | Please note we cannot use Google or any other copyrighted sources as a source in OSM, see osm.wiki/FAQ#Why_don't_you_just_use_Google_Maps/whoever_for_your_data? |
147623707 | over 1 year ago | Hi,
In OSM, towns (osm.wiki/Tag:place=town) are considered to be larger than villages, but smaller than cities. While there isn't a set cutoff for what is considered a city or town, in the Portland metro area incorporated places with 50K or more people are typically tagged as cities while those less are tagged as towns and villages. |
147426687 | over 1 year ago | Hi,
|
147239375 | over 1 year ago | Hi,
Instead, I recommend using lane_markings=yes to show that these roads have centerlines (osm.wiki/Key:lane_markings) |
146424166 | over 1 year ago | For multipolygons such as this track (osm.org/relation/7724479), the tags should only be on the relation itself and not on the member ways. |
146256934 | over 1 year ago | Also I highly doubt that a public school in California would be religious |
146256934 | over 1 year ago | Please note that only buildings should be tagged with building=*. Since this are is encompassing the entire school grounds, just amenity=school is sufficient |
146307231 | over 1 year ago | Hi,
|
146201433 | over 1 year ago | I believe Magnolia being secondary here makes more sense as it's important to distinguish Magnolia from other surrounding primary roads such as Beach and Brookhurst. Those streets get a lot more traffic, which is evident by how they have three or even four lanes in each direction as opposed to just two. |
145777240 | over 1 year ago | While functional classification maps are a good start to identify what highway classifications roads should be, I would avoid following them one hundred percent of the time. A lot of the times functional classifications are based on previously planned projects that were never completed. For example, Gilbert from La Palma to Orangethorpe was likely classified as a minor arterial because of a planned overpass over I-5. Lately, the US community has been moving towards forming a coherent network for each classification, meaning that stubs, particularly secondary and above, should be avoided (see osm.wiki/United_States/Highway_classification) Here's a useful diary entry from another fellow mapper on classifying roads in the LA area: osm.org/user/willkmis/diary/399345 |
145588046 | over 1 year ago | Almost got it, for multipolygons you only need to have the tags you want on the relation. It looks like the outer way also had `natural=wood`. Since this way seemed to follow the park boundary, I've changed the outer way of this multipolygon to be the way used for the park in osm.org/changeset/145588701 |