New MapRoulette Challenge: Crossing Ways
Publicado por mvexel o 30 de Xuño de 2014 en English. Última actualización no 1 de Xullo de 2014.We created a new MapRoulette challenge over at Telenav: Crossing Ways. As always with the Telenav-generated challenges, this one is US only, because we currently only process OpenStreetMap data for the United States. We are working on extending support for other regions.
TL;DR –> On to MapRoulette!!
The Crossing Ways challenge is pretty straightforward and should make for an easy challenge for novice mappers looking for something to fix. It detects ways that cross, but neither way is tagged as a bridge or tunnel. Here is an example:
If you open this up in iD or JOSM, you will be able to tell the required resolution from the aerial imagery:
In this case, the ways should be connected as there is clearly an intersection. Another possibility is that there actually should be a bridge or tunnel tag on either of the ways.
In this particular case, you can see that there actually is a node at the intersection, but it does not connect both ways. In JOSM, it displays as a ‘skinny node’:
.
In this case, you can use JOSM’s ‘Join’ function (shortcut ‘J’) to connect both ways. In iD, a node connecting two ways will be grey, and a regular node will be white:
If you use iD, you can just drag an existing node to the intersection to snap the two ways together, or drag a virtual node to the intersection to create a new intersection node. (Virtual nodes appear between two existing nodes and allow you to quickly create a new node on a way, an example shown below.)
There are currently around 19,000 cases in the US alone, so let’s get on fixing these annoying bugs in OSM!
Parola
Comentario de todrobbins no 30 de Xuño de 2014 ás 17:01
Great work mvexel!
Comentario de jumbanho no 30 de Xuño de 2014 ás 17:27
Does this work for cycle/foot- ways, paths and tracks, too?
Comentario de mvexel no 30 de Xuño de 2014 ás 18:18
jumbanho - those are excluded for now, but it’s a good idea for a followup challenge.
Comentario de Alan no 1 de Xullo de 2014 ás 01:01
I think the URL in your last link “On to MapRoulette” is broken. Needs the http:, I think.
Comentario de mvexel no 1 de Xullo de 2014 ás 03:08
Thanks @Alan, fixing…
Comentario de AndiG88 no 1 de Xullo de 2014 ás 06:08
I think http://keepright.at/ also displays those, if you want to fix them outside the US.
Comentario de Pieren no 1 de Xullo de 2014 ás 13:11
I’m assigned to this “challenge”: http://openstreetmap.us/iD/release/#id=w157598950&map=18.72/-122.27129/47.50951
What is wrong here ? is it possible that “bridge=viaduct” is not recognized by the QA tool ?
Comentario de mvexel no 1 de Xullo de 2014 ás 14:51
Pieren: You have discovered a bug. bridge=viaduct was not processed and will appear as false positives. We are working on a fix! This is less than 1% of bridges in the US, most are just bridge=yes. We discovered another bug where we did not recognize _link ways that are also tagged as bridge (or tunnel). This is also being fixed.
Thanks for reporting!
Comentario de mvexel no 1 de Xullo de 2014 ás 14:53
AndiG88 - correct. I still want to get closer collaboration with KeepRight, and have been in touch with the author before, but due to a lack of time on my part, I haven’t been able to follow up.