OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
46993726 over 8 years ago

Just trying to give you some friendly advice/feedback from someone who's contributed a lot, before you make a lot of detailed but sub-optimal edits that may impact you or another map editor/data user in the future.

45703083 over 8 years ago

Welcome to OSM! Wondering why you split the park into two pieces when they are overlapping? Appears it could just be one big area.

46993726 over 8 years ago

So, why not just make one big grass area? Or if you really want to do detailed micro-mapping, grass areas should end next to the paths. (I just edited the small triangle west of the pitches in this way in case you're unsure what I mean)

46646003 over 8 years ago

I'm wondering why you are adding wikidata tags to individual highway ways (ie osm.org/way/45782591), and not to relations that collect those ways in a route (ie osm.org/relation/1630660)?

46993726 over 8 years ago

Welcome to OSM. I'm wondering why you created so many different grass areas in this park? It appears they are bounded by the paths. It seems overcomplicated and having the areas along the paths makes it harder to edit in the future. Plus, the grassy areas outside the paths are not tagged.

47162651 over 8 years ago

Welcome to OSM! I notice that in these edits you've tried to create "islands" in landuse areas in the wrong way. You should be using multipolygon relations. See osm.wiki/Relation:multipolygon on the wiki for a description, and the Relations section of the iD Editor help for how to create them.

44947184 over 8 years ago

wondering why you added sport=sport_centre to the Power Sport shop?

47184571 over 8 years ago

Hi, the consensus tag for places like this is leisure=fitness_centre. Please see osm.wiki/Gym_/_Fitness_centre for more info.

46626226 over 8 years ago

Hi and welcome to OSM! It looks like you unintentionally overlapped the lake and park to the west of 450th Ave. Can you try to fix it? Let me know if you have problems. Cheers!

46715505 over 8 years ago

cool, thanks for the reply. happy mapping!

46715505 over 8 years ago

It seems like many of these Daybreak streets are not present in the most recent imagery. Are they extremely new, or just planned? If planned, they should be tagged as proposed--see osm.wiki/Key:proposed

46377427 over 8 years ago

message sent to user about questionable edits

46377832 over 8 years ago

unclear what uniforge means and why it is tagged bare rock??

44974121 over 8 years ago

hi, just a quick note that sports_centre should use the leisure key, not amenity

44310057 over 8 years ago

Hi, welcome to OSM and thanks for adding so much detail! One tip--please add building=yes to shops or amenitys when they occupy the entire building. It accurately describes the feature and improves rendering. (for ex, McGlynn Pharmacy)

38954250 over 8 years ago

Hi, just a friendly reminder that in OSM street names should be fully spelled out, even street type or street directions that are typically abbreviated. For example, "Xeon Street Northwest" instead of "Xeon St NW"

40965715 over 8 years ago

Hi, just a note that fitness places should be tagged leisure=fitness_centre, not as amenity. See osm.wiki/Gym_/_Fitness_centre

40136048 over 8 years ago

this should probably be tagged either leisure=sports_centre or leisure=fitness_centre. see osm.wiki/Gym_/_Fitness_centre

42011956 over 8 years ago

not sure why you added amenity=fitness_center back to this? leisure=fitness_centre is the de facto standard, see osm.wiki/Gym_/_Fitness_centre

43906175 over 8 years ago

curious what all these "zcolo-memphis" changesets are about--the ways all seem to be untagged. is it related to the map on this page? http://www.zayo.com/facilities/7620-appling-ctr/