Fixed in osm.org/changeset/50250480

Removed in osm.org/changeset/107007911

Removed in osm.org/changeset/47257686

Removed in osm.org/changeset/74828104

Here is a list of issues related (primarily) to the "new paths" changesets by MrRaspi:

- Duplicate nodes in a way:
http://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=geometry&lon=34.29645&lat=31.39732&zoom=10&overlays=duplicate_node_in_way

- Unconnected nodes:
http://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=routing&lon=34.29645&lat=31.39732&zoom=10&overlays=unconnected_open_ends_1

- Single node in a way:
http://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=geometry&lon=34.29645&lat=31.39732&zoom=10&overlays=single_node_in_way

- Self-intersecting ways:
http://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=geometry&lon=34.29645&lat=31.39732&zoom=10&overlays=self_intersection_ways,self_intersection_points

The "new paths" changeset include:
osm.org/changeset/106666666
osm.org/changeset/106666674
osm.org/changeset/106666680
osm.org/changeset/106666686
osm.org/changeset/106666689
osm.org/changeset/106666694
osm.org/changeset/106666695
osm.org/changeset/106666705
osm.org/changeset/106666722

The above changesets include 80776 new elements.

All new ways are highways. The new highways were not connected to any existing highways.

All new ways had the non-standard "Shape_Leng" tag, indicating a potential import form an undisclosed external source. None of the changesets had a "source" tag.

Thanks!
This is in line with the comments I received from other users

https://www.facebook.com/groups/israelhikingmap/posts/4139372262784602/

The ways were removed in osm.org/changeset/105555961

@ratrun, @MrRapsi,

Is there any progress in resolving this issue?
What did the DWG decide about it?

Hello Ilya,

In this edit you tagged the pedestrian bridge in Mitzpe Ramon with access=no and foot=no

The bridge is part of the Israel National Trail. was it a temporary closure or was the trail moved?

Thanks,
Zeev

שלום גיא,

תודה על תרומתך למפה של
OSM

בעריכה זו הוספת תגיות
acccess=no foot=no
לדרך המובילה לשמורת נחל התנינים ולטיילת נחל התנינים. בכך נחסמה הגישה לשניהם ברגל וברכב.

osm.org/way/178751929

האם זו היתה חסימה זמנית או שיש גישה אחרת לכניסה לשמורה ולטיילת?

בברכה,
זאב

As far as I know, there is no officially-declared Nature Reserve in this place. The media coverage is about a local plan (תב"ע), which has not been approved yet.
Moreover, after such a plan is approved, the appropriate minister has to issue a declaration in order to make the planned area into an official Nature Reserve.

As far as I know, the Apollonia Eco-Park you mapped is also at some planning stage and is not an officially-declared Nature Reserve yet.
osm.org/node/8354876766

Israel has dozens, if not hundreds, of Nature Reserves in different proposal stages. Many of them have not made any progress for many years. In my opinion, there is very little value to the general public by mapping them in OSM, even if the mapping will be done using appropriate tagging.

Hi,

I'm not aware of any official declaration of this area as a nature reserve.

Please clarify.

Thanks,
Zeev

Well, that's complicated...

How frequently does the status of this gate change between open and closed?
If it changes often than I would go on the safe side and tag it with motor_vehicle=no.
If it rarely changes its state, I would tag it with the latest status.

תודה!

Hi,

In this edit you added a gate at a junction. As a result, it is not clear which way is blocked by the gate.

Please see the wiki on this subject
osm.wiki/Key:barrier#How_to_map_barrier_nodes

Thanks!

Hi,

In this edit you added a gate on a track (double).
Does it allow motor vehicles to enter?
If not, please add "motor_vehicle=no", since the default for gates in Israel is "motor_vehicle=yes".

Thanks!

Perhaps barrier=motorcycle_barrier would be a more appropriate tag.

osm.wiki/Tag:barrier%3Dmotorcycle_barrier

Hi,

The barrier=con tag in
osm.org/node/8281694833
is probably a typo.

Best regards,
Zeev

תודה!
השאלה היתה על השער/מחסום
לא חשבתי שיש בעיה עם הסיווג של הדרך
אני לא מצליח לראות את הגדר או את השער באורטופוטו

Hi,

The wiki says that "barrier=entrance defines an opening (a gap or hole) in a linear barrier=*. "
This is not the case here. See
osm.wiki/Tag:barrier=entrance?uselang=en

To override the default access to a highway, put the needed tags on the highway itself.

For example, for highway=path the default access includes foot=yes and bicycle=yes so there is no need to put them on such highways.

Best Regards,
Zeev