zstadler's Comments

Changeset	მუჟამს	კომენტარი
164099251	6 დღაშ კინოხ	Hello TedIsAwesome, Thank you for your contributions to OSM! The Israeli West Bank barrier cannot be tagged as a boundary because it has an open geometry that cannot be represented as a multipolygon. osm.wiki/w/index.php?title=Relation:boundary&uselang=en says about boundary relations: They are defined in a similar manner as multipolygons: they must contain at least one outer way, and additional ways can be used to define enclaves or exclaves. This changeset was therefore reverted.
21734878	8 დღაშ კინოხ	מדובר כאן על מחסום. בניגוד לכל אלמנט אחר במתחם, מתבקש שתהיה לו תגית access בהנחה שאנחנו יכולים להסכים עד כאן, לדעתי מדויק יותר לתייג עם access=customers מאשר עם access=yes
21734878	8 დღაშ კინოხ	תוכל לצטט או לתת מראה מקום של המשפט/הפסקא/ות שהובילו אותך להבנה הזו?
21734878	8 დღაშ კინოხ	תיקנתי
21734878	8 დღაშ კინოხ	לאיזה אלמנט אתה מתייחס?
156624223	8 დღაშ კინოხ	Hello Sojo13, Thank you for your contributions to OSM! In this edit you have added a "layer=1" tag to osm.org/way/729392502 without adding a bridge tag. Was that done in order to avoid JOSM warnings about crossings between a highway and a stream?
161807035	14 დღაშ კინოხ	אם היה, הייתי ממפה אותו
169389321	14 დღაშ კინოხ	Hi Gizem, Thank you for responding. In osm.org/changeset/169687330 I have reverted this changeset in order to restore the paths within the public park and removed non-existant paths. Best regards, zstadler
169389321	16 დღაშ კინოხ	Hello GizemBaba, I'm planning to revert this changeset in 2 days unless you respond. Best regards, zstadler
169389321	19 დღაშ კინოხ	Hello GizemBaba, Thank you for your contribution to OSM and your first contribution in Israel! In this edit you have removed several paths. One and half of the paths connect the park with Ibn Gabirol Street. However, you have also deleted paths in the park, which are not private and are clearly seen in the satellite imagery. Is there another reason for deleting the following ways: osm.org/way/913602638 osm.org/way/913602639 osm.org/way/913602640 osm.org/way/913602641 osm.org/way/913602642 osm.org/way/913602697 Private paths and driveways that exist on the ground, should be kept on the map. As the wiki explains, roads can be tagged with access=private tag "for example because it is behind a gate, or has posted signage that indicates that the property owner has chosen to disallow access by the general public". See osm.wiki/Tag:access%3Dprivate#Road_usage. It is somewhat strange that your first edit ever in Israel is based on residents complaints. Could you share these complaints and clarify how these complaints reached you. Thank you for your cooperation, zstadler
169090297	21 დღაშ კინოხ	Hello Rawaz, Thank you for your contributions to OSM. In this edit you have modified osm.org/way/968697169 and as a result, osm.org/relation/13035771 is no longer a valid closed multipolygon. Could you fix that?
169140189	24 დღაშ კინოხ	סימן שזה היה מזמן :-)
169140189	24 დღაშ კინოხ	תודה!
169140189	24 დღაშ კინოხ	היי Flayer, האם הבסיס פונה? למשל, עבור השכונה שנראה שאמורה לקום במקומו?
116116014	დოხ. 2 თუთაშ კინოხ	Thank you for the clarification. Interesting!
116116014	დოხ. 2 თუთაშ კინოხ	Hello InfosReseaux Thank you for your contributions to OSM. This edit changed the "usage" tag of way 544376704 https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/544376704 It was changed from "usage=headrace" to "usage=transmission". If I understand the other tags correctly, this canal is used for hydroelectric power generation, and usage=headrace seems more appropriate. See the "usage" table at osm.wiki/Tag:waterway=canal?uselang=en#Tags_used_in_combination Bonjour InfosReseaux, Merci pour vos contributions à OSM. Cette modification a changé la clé "usage" du chemin 544376704 : https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/544376704 Elle a été modifiée de "usage=headrace" à "usage=transmission". Si je comprends bien les autres clés, ce canal est utilisé pour la production d’hydroélectricité, et "usage=headrace" semble plus approprié. Voir le tableau "Destination" à la page suivante : osm.wiki/FR:Tag:waterway%3Dcanal#Destination ainsi que le schéma à la ligne suivante : https://www.mdpi.com/energies/energies-11-02994/article_deploy/html/images/energies-11-02994-g001.png
167733416	დოხ. 2 თუთაშ კინოხ	אפשר, במקביל, לפנות לממפה ולבקש שהוא יפסיק למפות וימחק את מה שכבר מופה. אפשר להסביר שהמתקנים האלו מגינים על חייהם של אזרחים וחשיפת מיקומם עלול לעלות בחיי אדם. עכשיו, לצערי, שנים משלושת האתרים שמחקת שוחזרו ואז נמחקו שוב... "מלחמת עריכה" שכזו היא לא משהו שמוסיף לשם הטוב של קהילת הממפים הישראלית בכלל, ולמעורבים בפרט
167527182	დოხ. 2 თუთაშ კინოხ	This changeset was reverted in changeset 167696716
167668550	დოხ. 2 თუთაშ კინოხ	This changeset was reverted in changeset 167696739
167668578	დოხ. 2 თუთაშ კინოხ	This changeset was reverted in changeset 167696758