Hello Ophirh2,

In this edit the tracktype of osm.org/way/730666408 was changed from grade3 to grade5.

According to the Israel mapping guidelines at osm.wiki/Israel#Ways_Belonging_to_a_Trail
grade5 is the most demanding grade for 4WD vehicles:

> Unpaved road requiring deferential locks and high clearance - "דרך עפר לרכב שטח "נעול

It is very unusual to find such roads in a flatland like the Zvulun valley. tracktype=grade4 is also not common in such areas.

Can you please revisit this classification?

Thanks!

Hello Zero0000,

I understand you are new to OSM.
No boundaries were removed in this changeset.

Please see the OSM wiki regarding the "subarea" tag:

"Optional, disputed and redundant (references to sublevels may also be found with spatial queries, provided that there's no overlap between similar subdivisions). Also referencing other relations makes editing more complicated in some cases."

source: osm.wiki/Relation:boundary#Relation_members

Best regards,
Zeev

Hello Onceinawhile,

The changes in this edit are unrelated to any political event or view.

As the title says, the "subarea" members of the relations were removed because the use of such members is disputed and redundant.

Best regards,
Zeev

Thanks!

Hello sivan00

The south end of osm.org/way/223061161 was disconnected in this edit.

The way is part of the blue marked trail osm.org/relation/2959038 and this trail now has an internal disconnect.

Was this done on purpose or is it a mistake?

Hello ondz,

In this edit the colour tag of osm.org/way/431079419 was changed from black to red. You may have missed the note on this segment saying:

"DO NOT CHANGE THE colour TAG before visiting the trail. This is a black trail while the official map marks it as red"

Currently, there is a T junction of 3 red trails at the north end of this road.

Have you visited that junction and seen the 3 red trail marks?

The junction as it is seen on the Israel Hiking and Biking map:
https://israelhiking.osm.org.il/map/18.00/33.1439/35.6649

Thanks!

I've added a trail relation in
osm.org/changeset/81495834

Thank you!

Do you know if it was done by some Palestinian organization, like an equivalent of KKL, or was it done by individuals?

I'm asking because OSM mapping for Israel required that a "route" relation will be created for hiking and biking trails, and some of the information there is the "operator" tag that captures that organization responsible for creating/defining the trail.

Usually, but there are probably exceptions, the map does not capture the color of trails created by individuals.

Hello,

osm.org/way/729392502 was added in this edit as a red cycleway.

Who marked the trail in red? Is it a private? kkl?

Hello,

osm.org/way/214764908 was marked as a black trail in this edit.

Usually, short trails to camp-sites are not marked on the ground. Have you seen a sign there like this, or is it a mapping mistake?

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/9/9a/%D7%A9%D7%97%D7%95%D7%A8.PNG/45px-%D7%A9%D7%97%D7%95%D7%A8.PNG

Done. Thanks!

Hello nirlhn,

osm.org/node/5931247613 was added in this edit, but this gate is not connected to any road.
Is this a mistake or incomplete mapping?

Hello,

osm.org/node/1956144558 was added in this edit, but it is a gate disconnected from any way. Is this a mistake or incomplete mapping?

Hello Yakir,

osm.org/node/721213713 is a gate on a stream, not on a highway.
Is this a mistake, or is there a path/tunnel under the main road?

No response. Way was deleted.

Hello BMM994,

osm.org/way/739814866 was added in this edit, but it has no tags. Is this a mistake or an incomplete mapping?

Hello BMM994,

osm.org/way/697956027 was added in this edit, but it has no tags. Is this a mistake or an incomplete mapping?

Hello BMM994,

osm.org/way/683922150 was added in this edit, but it has no tags. Is this a mistake or an incomplete mapping?

Hello BMM994,

osm.org/way/680608097 was added in this edit, but it has no tags. Is this a mistake or an incomplete mapping?