OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
81519204 over 5 years ago

Hello/ Thanks for mapping
a few remarks. You mapped quite a lot of highways and tagged them mostly as unclassified, despite most of them should be residential. In most cases you also connected them with nodes to buildings. This are serious errors which have to be solved.
Please review your knowledge how to tag and map highways.
Best regards

83207338 over 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping here
You have had a lot of work here.
A few remarks. You mapped additionally to the already preselected buildings quite a number of buildings. Please square these as well with the Q key in RapiD,
You include the shadow of a building in your mapping. They are no part of the building itself. It says something of the size of a wall, and that it is above groundlevel, so do not include them
Best regards and keep mapping

83591670 over 5 years ago

Hello Sam, Thanks for mapping here
A request. Please square all the buildings you map with the Q key in RapiD before uploading
You mapped also 5 objects as natural=wood.. In your case just a single node. Normally you should map an area and call it natural=wood. In this project only mapping of highways and buildings is requested. So, there is no need to map other features and do not map them.
Please pay also attention on the issues the triangle on the right hand menu shows and try to solve them before uploading your work
Best regards and keep mapping

83536777 over 5 years ago

Hello Abdica212
Thanks for mapping here
Please take (another) look at the instruction page how to tag highways.
You tag track on an thoroughgoing going road and tag residential as access to a single dwelling in a rural area.
I corrected them
Best regards and keep mapping

83122982 over 5 years ago

Hello lilyzy
Thanks for mapping here
Please reread the way highways has to be tagged on the instruction page.
When a road is wide enough it should not be tagged as Path. <2 mtr
Best regards

83248995 over 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping here
a request. Please square the buildings you map with the Q key RapiD
Best regards

81343097 over 5 years ago

Hi. another issue
You map quite a number of buildings much oversized and connect nodes of buildings to each other . Please be more accurate when mapping buildings and square each building with the Q key in iDeditor
Thanks

81343097 over 5 years ago

Hello Jean Lau
Thanks for mapping here
I review work and have a remark.
You include the shadow of a building in the mapping itself. The shadow shows that an object is above groundlevel and not part of the object itself. Please take that in mind at future mappings. Best regards

83366843 over 5 years ago

Hello.
Thanks for mapping here
A remark. Please map highways in urban areas and districts as highway=residential.
(Except Main roads)
Best regards

83106119 over 5 years ago

Hello Allison.
You might be right with your comments, but this is no the place to address it.
We have to deal with it.

btw I, and most validators work with JOSM and MAXAR imagery ( most recent) and map missing objects as well.
You ignored my comments on your mappings. :-)
Best regards

83106119 over 5 years ago

Hi. I've got some other issues
Try to keep in mind that highways=track
are to be used as access to farmland, woodland and wilderness.
Unclassified highways always to be used to connect dwellings. villages etc to other highways.
Try to connect all paths and highways to each other, so they are a network.
Please do not connect nodes of features to highways and buildings.
This project ask just map buildings and highways. No need to map other features like farmland etc.
You can add the surface tag ground to the highways unclassified, residential and service
Best regards

83106119 over 5 years ago

Hello Allison
Thanks for mapping here
A few remarks. Please do not use the tag 'footway' for tiny(narrow) road. Use Path instead. more generic, everything but cars can use these.
There is no need to map all traces in farmland with paths. Try to restrict to path/highways coming from major roads and leading to dwellings , farms etc.
When they are visible en on short distance of a road there is no need to map those small roads.
Please pay also attention and solve the issues which arise on the issuetriangle on the righthand menu on RapiD
Best regards and keep mapping

83204019 over 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping here.
A short remark. Please do not use the tag "footway" use " path", is more generic because these path will be used by everything but cars.
There is no need to map all short segments leading from a highway to nearby dwellings. When they are visible from the road, there is no need to map them.
Please be sure to square each (not round) building with the Q key.
Best regards

82487865 over 5 years ago

Hello. Thanks for mapping here
A request. Please review your knowledge about tagging highways.
The tag secondary highway is a main road between villages, not in rural areas local in the fields. Tag " road" should be avoided. Use a more specific tag,
Also, solve the issues shown by the issue triangle at the righthand menu
Best regards

81966616 over 5 years ago

Hello Nathalie, Thanks for mapping here.
Sorry to say, but your first attempt to map did not work very well.
You made nearly every error a beginner mapper can make,. This is not to blame you, We are helping you with that.
A few errors. You mapped a highway over an existing highway.
No idea if it was shown in the imagery, but you mapped a piece of land as a building, and included Layer1
Layer 1 means that the object is above another object, This is used at bridges, to see the difference with an underlying river. so that they are not at the same level
Always square a building (if not round) with the Q key in iDeditor
Do never connect nodes of buildings to other features like highways and landuse .
You mapped lots of features as highway=track
highway=track is only to be used as access to farmland and woodland
use tag unclassified for good visible roads and path where the width is < 1.8 mtr (Hardly visible, no traces of 4 wheel cars)
You also duplicated a number of highways
Please take the time to get yourself familiar with the mapping course
See this page
https://learnosm.org/en/beginner/id-editor/#issues
I solve the issues here
Take also a look to the error triangle in the right hand menu. Solve the issues before you upload your work.
Best regards and keep mapping

81518121 over 5 years ago

Hello Smmda. Thanks for mapping
A remark. Please tag highways in rural areas not as residential but as unclassified
Best regards

82661939 over 5 years ago

High Daniel
Please look to the issue triangle which reports errors. Here you overlooked the request to connect the highway you mapped to an path a bit further on>
Best regards

82662204 over 5 years ago

Hi Daniel
Her you mapped a highway in rural area as residential. Unclassified should be a better choice here
best regards

82842104 over 5 years ago

Hello Daniel
On this task you did map a few buildings but did not map any highway which were good visible here.
I completed this
Best regards

82660624 over 5 years ago

Hello DanielApp
I review work of (new) mappers and noticed here some issues.
On this task RapiD shows a part of a highway which you did not map at all
Please map each highway except when it is obvious that it not a highway at all
Best regards