OpenStreetMap-logo OpenStreetMap

JOSM tip for squaring buildings

Skrevet af OpenBrian den 16 maj 2014 på English

We all know about Q in JOSM, which will make the angles in a building 90°. But isn’t it annoying when you have one building, you are adding an adjacent building, and when you square the corners it affects the first building? Here’s a pro-tip. When squaring the second building, select it, then add 2 nodes from the first building into your selection. Then hit Q. It will use the first building as a baseline for the second. Notice 2 nodes are highlighted red.

square building

E-mail-ikon Bluesky-ikon Facebook-ikon LinkedIn-ikon Mastodon-ikon Telegram-ikon X-ikon

Diskussion

Kommentar fra Vincent de Phily skrevet 16. maj 2014 kl. 15:39

Thanks, didn’t know about this one. For the given example I’d have used extrude instead anyway, but I can see other cases where it’ll be usefull.

Kommentar fra ToeBee skrevet 16. maj 2014 kl. 15:54

You can also select multiple ways and use Q on all of them at the same time. Like a row of connected buildings.

Kommentar fra AndiG88 skrevet 17. maj 2014 kl. 13:48

For the given example I’d have used extrude instead anyway, but I can see other cases where it’ll be usefull.

Or just the (B)uilding tool.

Kommentar fra OpenBrian skrevet 17. maj 2014 kl. 14:42

I should mention my use case is turning 1 building into n stores.

Extrude doesn’t build a second store. It will just move an edge. Though shift+extrude will leave nodes in place.

The building tool drops extra nodes, i.e. it doesn’t join them on adjacent areas.

The terracing plugin works very well. The problem with the terracing plugin is it assumes all “stores” in a building are the same width and it’s hard to adjust that.

I also like the “Split Object” function which belongs to utilsplugins2, iirc.

Kommentar fra Vincent de Phily skrevet 17. maj 2014 kl. 23:31

Alt+extrude will create a second store.

The building tool is great for simple things, but I find that it asumes too much (such as the value of the building tag or the angle of the next building) while not handling L/T-shaped buildings and leaving unshared nodes everywhere. Extrude is less advanced but more versatile.

Kommentar fra AndiG88 skrevet 18. maj 2014 kl. 03:16

The building tool drops extra nodes, i.e. it doesn’t join them on adjacent areas.

Yes, it does unless I misunderstood you.

OpenStreetMap Building Tool

OpenStreetMap Building Tool

Kommentar fra Hedaja skrevet 20. maj 2014 kl. 13:46

thats a good tip one problem i allways have with q is that all angles are made 90°. Is there a posibility to exclude certain corners?

Kommentar fra Domiss skrevet 21. maj 2014 kl. 06:58

It is much simpler way to have angles different from 90°. Just press ‘a’ twice when you start drawing. All angles will be alligned to round ones (90°, 60°, 45°, 30°, …), but it is of course still possible to draw other ones. More, there will be guiding lines which helps draw parallel (not only) lines with the same lenght.

Log ind for at kommentere