Hi! Welcome to OSM! I notice you've added some roads here ( osm.org/way/476753044#map=18/7.25729/5.22783 ) . Be sure to tag the way to record that it's a road. Don't just leave it untagged! :)

Cool. That makes sense. Maybe that's why I didn't see anything on the aerial imagery

Hi! I notice you added 2 picnic areas ( osm.org/changeset/46708390 and osm.org/way/468315804 ) in this change. You added a name of "picnic shelter" and "Free Barbeques". I hope you don't mind, but I removed those names ( in this change osm.org/changeset/46708390 ). In OSM we don't add a description to name. The name should be used for things like "Jim's BBQ Shelter".

Hi there! I notice you mapped 2 things here, and I'm not sure it's correct. "Unused field" is that really it's *name*, or just the description? In OSM we use the `name` tag for the actual name. Likewise for the "Empty Field". You also didn't tag Empty field as anything, you need to describe it somehow.

I've fixed both up here osm.org/changeset/46675706

I'm doing Jochen Topf's Area fixing maproulette challenges ( http://area.jochentopf.com/fixing.html ), and one of the highlighted topology errors was here.

No, I've never been to the area, so I'll defer to your local knowledge. It looks like I was misreading the aerial imagery. :)

Hi! Careful when adding buildings. You need to add the "building=yes" tag. You can't just leave it as "area=yes"

Hi. I've changed some of your mapping of buildings in this changeset ( osm.org/changeset/46653143 ). You had a building tagged as a mulitpolygon relation with a outer and inner role. This means you're mapping a building with a hole. I don't think this is the case, from the aerial imagery, so I've changed it.

Hi! Careful with the duplicate buildings here. You have a few buildings on top of each other. The JOSM validator flags this as an error before upload, maybe have a look at those errors before uploading?

Hi. In this changeset you added exactly the same buildings as you did in ( osm.org/changeset/25264593 ). they are exactly on top of the others! How did you manage that? I've deleted these new overlapping buildings in this changeset osm.org/changeset/46652417

Hi. I notice you adeded a lot of `natural=bare_rock` areas here. You state that the source is Mapbox Satellite. However I can't see any rocks in this area on that imagery. It just all looks like forest/woods to me. Is there another Mapbox satellite source you used, or the default one in JOSM? Maybe I just didn't know what to look out for in the imagery

Yes! I forgot to do that there. You could call it "Knock" or "Knock Civil Parish".

Sure., So long as you're aware that the OSi data isn't gospel! 👍🙂

One thing about the OSi townlands: they are simplified/generalised to 20m "resoltuion", so OSM can easily be better/more accurate

Hi. You've added a very large building here: ( osm.org/way/447695198 ). Is this really one large building?

How come you've aded 3 different CPs? Shouldn't there only be one, Drummaul. What's going on with the little ones likw "Drummail/Antrim"? It's not in Logainm, and the Memorial Atlas maps imply it's not a separate CP

Hi! You added the `opening_hours` to the Pizza Hut (here osm.org/node/3965636965 ). The OSM opening_hours has a strict, machine parsable format. You can use a tool like YoHours ( http://projets.pavie.info/yohours/ ) draw in the hours and generate the OSM format. I did that here ( osm.org/changeset/46169421 ). Hope that helps.

Hi! I notice you've mapped a few buildings on top of each other ( osm.org/way/364470455 and osm.org/way/364472804 ). Do you know about the JOSM validator? It can be used

If it's just a simple mistake that's fine, just delete one of them. :) If there's more complicated building stuff going on (multi-levels, courtyards etc), then maybe we can map it better?

Hi! 🙂 I wonder if I can ask one thing about some of the buildings you have added here. Sometimes you have added a node inside a building with the same `shop` tag. e.g. This building ( osm.org/way/364483936 ) is tagged `shop=greengrocer`, but inside it, there's this stand alone node ( osm.org/node/3713347841 ) which is also (and only) tagged `shop=greengrocer`.

Under [OSM's "On feature, One OSM object"](osm.wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element) guideline, that would imply there are *two* greengrocers here! And I don't think that's what you mean, right? 😄

I'm fixing up some of the other instances of this in Dar now, but I thought I should talk to you directly as well. 🙂

Hi! Welcome to OSM! Thanks for your contributions here. :) Just one minor point, I notice that several of you were editing at the same time, and 3 of you have been editing at the same place, and yous each have put the same building at the same time. Maybe in future don't edit the same area at exactly the same time as other mappers? If you're using a tasking manager then that should take care of that.

Here's the 3 changesets:
osm.org/changeset/33494939
osm.org/changeset/33494627
osm.org/changeset/33494507

Hi! Welcome to OSM! Thanks for your contributions here. :) Just one minor point, I notice that several of you were editing at the same time, and 3 of you have been editing at the same place, and yous each have put the same building at the same time. Maybe in future don't edit the same area at exactly the same time as other mappers? If you're using a tasking manager then that should take care of that.

Here's the 3 changesets:
osm.org/changeset/33494939
osm.org/changeset/33494627
osm.org/changeset/33494507