OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
50359540 over 6 years ago

This looks like a mechanical edit! You changed the `ele` tag of many culverts to a `height` tag. (e.g. osm.org/way/338049308 ). But the correct tag (instead of `ele`) is `layer`!

Please try to be careful. There is great benefit to actually _looking_ at the data before changing it. 🙂

36053224 over 6 years ago

Hi! You added a lot of `leisure=park` but on nodes. It's best to draw an area for them. 🙂

43786792 over 6 years ago

Careful of the building mapping here! 😁

48666487 over 6 years ago

This looks like a mechanical edit. 😉 If you look at the individual data directly you can sometimes see other mistakes that need correcting.

Like this "building" which is mapped as as a square power line ( osm.org/way/454413597/history ). 😉

61071657 over 6 years ago

Careful about overlapping roads here. 🙂

52137125 over 6 years ago

You've mapped a few trees in this change and added a teeny little way to each one (e.g. v1 of this way osm.org/way/525560134/history )

43770969 over 6 years ago

`leisure=park` should be on an area, not a node

43770928 over 6 years ago

You added a few untagged nodes here...

50454238 over 6 years ago

You added a lots of untagged nodes in this changeset....

48959044 over 6 years ago

Hi, in this changeset you have changed a lot of `building=house` to `building=yes` (e.g. osm.org/way/454858555/history ). Can you explain why you did that? `building=yes` is _less_ accurate than `building=house`. What makes you think these are not houses?

66337913 over 6 years ago

Hello. You added a "service" road right into the scout den ( osm.org/way/663555985 ). you marked it as `motor_vehicle=yes`, i.e. that one can drive a car along that little stretch. That seems weird to me, is that right?

47795335 over 6 years ago

Hello again! It's great that you want to add historic features to OSM. But we should really try to tag them properly..

51597990 over 6 years ago

Hello. You added Indenpendence Way here ( osm.org/way/520151921#map=16/10.5208/7.4398 ), is there any reason why the way/road beside it ( osm.org/way/520151922#map=16/10.5209/7.4397 ) doesn't have a name?

67054150 over 6 years ago

That monument seems a little large, does it really go into the canal? Mapillary implies it's much smaller.

41575574 over 6 years ago

That's what I figured. I changed it to `club=scout` which I think is the correct way to mark such a thing

osm.org/node/4358905692
osm.org/changeset/66773832
osm.wiki/Tag:club%3Dscout

41575574 over 6 years ago

Are you sure this is a camp site? In the middle of Dublin?!

66423353 over 6 years ago

I'm sorry, what? This isn't a HOT mapping task? What's going on?

66394139 over 6 years ago

Welcom to OSM! You asked for a review, so here it is.

This looks good. You've connected the footpath to the road correctly, and added extra details about the path (dirt).

Did you know about the "bird hide" tag ( osm.wiki/Tag:leisure%3Dbird_hide ) Perhaps you should add that too

26718907 over 6 years ago

Someone is saying this Crosscannon Cemetery

osm.org/note/1647150#c3469129

65598267 over 6 years ago

FYI, you don't need to put "Source=DigitalGlobe" on objects. The changeset can have the source.